Choosing the Rule to Solve a Triangle
Which facts call for the sine rule and which for the cosine rule; solving a triangle fully and finding its area; two triangles in one figure; and keeping enough figures in the working.
Before you start
- In lessons 6.3 to 6.6 you used the sine rule and the cosine rule, each to find a side and to find an angle. In lesson 6.2 you found the area of a triangle as from two sides and the angle between them.
- In Secondary 1 (lesson 3.11, Rounding Errors) you learnt to round once, at the end: (3 s.f.), but rounding to first gives .
Which Rule to Start With
In triangle , side is opposite angle , side opposite and side opposite . Three facts, at least one of them a side, fix a triangle, if any triangle has them at all (no triangle has sides 3 cm, 4 cm and 8 cm); but two sides and an angle not between them may fit two possible triangles, or none (lesson 6.4). Say in words what you know, then choose the rule.
| What you know | Start with | It finds |
|---|---|---|
| Two angles and a side | The sine rule (the third angle first, from the angle sum, if needed) | A side (lesson 6.3) |
| Two sides and an angle not between them | The sine rule, turned up | An angle: one triangle, or two possible triangles (lesson 6.4) |
| Two sides and the angle between them (the included angle) | The cosine rule | The third side (lesson 6.5) |
| Three sides | The cosine rule, rearranged | An angle, the one facing the longest side first (lesson 6.6) |
| Two sides and the angle between them | Area | The area (lesson 6.2) |
The test: is there a complete pair?
A complete pair is a side and the angle opposite it, both known.
If there is a complete pair, start with the sine rule:
If there is none but two angles are known, find the third from the angle sum: that makes a complete pair.
If there is still none (two sides and the included angle, or three sides), the sine rule cannot start: use the cosine rule, or
Example 1: Choosing the rule
For each triangle , say which rule to use first and what it finds. (a) , , cm (b) cm, cm, (c) cm, cm, cm (d) cm, cm,
Solution
(a) Two angles and a side, and with is a complete pair: the sine rule finds at once. The third angle, , then gives .
(b) Two sides and the angle between them: no side faces a known angle, so the cosine rule finds .
(c) Three sides: the cosine rule, rearranged, finds an angle. Start with , which faces the longest side.
(d) Two sides and an angle not between them; with is a complete pair. The sine rule, turned up, finds . The angle given faces the longer side given (), so there is one triangle and is acute.
(a) Sine rule, for (b) cosine rule, for (c) cosine rule, for (d) sine rule, for (one triangle)
Solving a Triangle Fully
To solve a triangle is to find all three sides and all three angles. The area then follows from any two sides and the angle between them.
The order of the steps
1. If two angles are known, find the third from the angle sum. Then, with a complete pair, use the sine rule; without one (two sides and the included angle, or three sides), use the cosine rule first: its answer makes a complete pair.
2. For a second angle after the cosine rule, use the sine rule only for an angle that cannot be obtuse: one facing a side that is not the longest. Otherwise use the cosine rule again.
3. The third angle from the angle sum, (if not found already); the last side by the sine rule.
4. The area by , with two sides and the angle between them.
Why step 2: gives only the acute angle (lesson 6.1). If the angle you want is obtuse, the sine rule gives minus it, with no warning. The largest angle faces the longest side, so only the angle facing the longest side can be obtuse. Every other angle is safe for the sine rule.
Example 2: Two angles and a side
In , cm, and . Solve the triangle, and find its area.
Solution
(∠ sum of △). Now cm with is a complete pair.
Sine rule, the side wanted on top: cm (3 s.f.)
cm (3 s.f.)
Area, with , and the angle between them, using the full value of :
Area cm (3 s.f.)
, cm, cm; the area is cm.
Example 3: Two sides and the included angle
In , cm, cm and . Solve the triangle, and find its area.
Solution
Two sides and the angle between them: no complete pair, so the cosine rule first.
cm (3 s.f.). Now with is a complete pair.
The longest side is cm, so , facing it, may be obtuse. faces cm, not the longest: it cannot be obtuse, so the sine rule is safe for .
so (1 d.p.)
(1 d.p.): obtuse, as it may be.
Area cm (3 s.f.)
cm, , ; the area is cm.
The trap in Example 3
Had you used the sine rule for : and gives .
Then would be , the largest angle, facing the shortest side: impossible. The true is The cosine rule for gives it directly:
Two Triangles in One Figure
When a figure holds two triangles, find the triangle with three facts and solve it for what the other triangle needs: usually the side the two triangles share. Carry its full value into the second triangle.
Example 4: Two triangles sharing a side
In the quadrilateral , cm, cm and . In , and . Find (a) , (b) , (c) the area of .
Solution
Triangle has only two angles: it needs a side. Triangle has three facts, so it comes first, for the shared side .
(a) In , two sides and the included angle: the cosine rule.
cm (3 s.f.)
(b) In : and faces it: a complete pair. faces the at . With the full value of :
(3 s.f.)
(c) : cm. , with , and the between them: cm.
Area of cm (3 s.f.)
(a) cm (b) cm (c) cm
Example 5: A point on a side
In , cm and . is the point on with cm and cm. Find (a) , (b) , (c) .
Solution
(a) has two sides and the included angle : the cosine rule.
cm (3 s.f.)
(b) faces cm, the longest side of , so it may be obtuse: the cosine rule again.
so obtuse.
(1 d.p.) (adj. ∠s on a str. line)
Or safely by the sine rule: faces cm, not the longest side. gives , and the same.
(c) In the whole triangle , cm: so cm (3 s.f.)
(a) cm (b) (c) cm
Accuracy: Round Only the Answer
Solving a triangle takes several steps, and each answer is used in the next. A value rounded part-way carries its rounding error into every later step, and the last figure of the answer can change.
Keeping enough figures
Keep the full value in the calculator (carry on from the display, or use the Ans key or the memory), and write intermediate values to at least 4 significant figures.
Round only the answers: lengths to 3 significant figures and angles to 1 decimal place, unless the question says otherwise.
Example 6: Rounding too early
In , cm, cm and . Find and . Then see what happens if is rounded before is found.
Solution
Cosine rule: so cm (3 s.f.)
faces cm, not the longest side ( cm), so the sine rule is safe.
With the full value: so (1 d.p.)
With rounded to : so the last figure is wrong.
With written to 4 significant figures, : right again.
cm and ; rounding to 3 significant figures first gives the wrong .
Common Mistakes
- Using the sine rule with no complete pair. In Example 3 no side faces a known angle: the sine rule cannot start.
- Finding an obtuse angle by the sine rule. After the cosine rule, use the sine rule only for an angle not facing the longest side; in Example 3 the sine rule for gives in place of .
- Forgetting the second triangle. With two sides and an angle not between them, when the angle given is acute and faces the shorter side, test (lesson 6.4).
- Starting with the triangle that has too few facts. In Example 4, has no side until is found in .
- Rounding in the middle. In Example 6, rounded to makes come out as in place of .
- Using with an angle that is not between the two sides.
Practice Questions
Give lengths correct to 3 significant figures, angles to 1 decimal place and areas to 3 significant figures. Say which rule you use and why before you use it. Try each question before opening its solution.
Question 1
For each triangle , say which rule to use first and what it finds. (a) cm, cm, (b) , , cm (c) cm, cm, (d) cm, cm, cm
ShowHide solution
(a) Two sides and the included angle: the cosine rule, for .
(b) Two angles and a side, but does not face a known angle: first then the sine rule for or .
(c) with is a complete pair: the sine rule, turned up, for . The angle given faces the longer side given, so there is one triangle.
(d) Three sides: the cosine rule, rearranged, for first (it faces the longest side).
(a) cosine rule, (b) angle sum, , then sine rule, or (c) sine rule, (d) cosine rule,
Question 2
In , cm, and . Solve the triangle and find its area.
ShowHide solution
and faces : a complete pair.
cm; cm
Area cm
, cm, cm; area cm
Question 3
In , cm, cm and . Solve the triangle and find its area.
ShowHide solution
Two sides and the included angle: so cm.
is obtuse, so is the longest side and and are both acute: the sine rule is safe. so
Area cm
cm, , ; area cm
Question 4
A triangle has sides cm, cm and cm. Find all its angles and its area.
ShowHide solution
Let , , . Three sides: the cosine rule for , facing the longest side. so
faces the shortest side, so it is acute: , so
Area cm
, , ; area cm
Question 5
In , cm, cm and . Solve the triangle and find its area.
ShowHide solution
Two sides and an angle not between them; with is a complete pair. faces the longer side given, so there is one triangle and is acute.
so
cm
Area cm
, , cm; area cm
Question 6
In , cm, cm and . Find the possible values of , and .
ShowHide solution
is acute and faces the shorter side given, so test for two triangles. ,
two possible triangles.
First: , cm. Second: , cm.
, , cm; or , , cm
Question 7
In , cm, cm and . Wei Jie finds by the cosine rule, then writes and gives . Explain his mistake and find .
ShowHide solution
so cm.
faces cm, the longest side, so it may be obtuse; gave only the acute angle. ( would make face the shortest side: impossible.)
Cosine rule: so
faces the longest side and is obtuse: (the sine rule gave ).
Question 8
In the quadrilateral , cm, cm and . In , and . Find (a) , (b) , (c) the area of .
ShowHide solution
(a) , cosine rule: so cm.
(b) facing . faces the : cm.
(c) and total cm.
(a) cm (b) cm (c) cm
Question 9
In , cm, cm and . is the point on with cm. Find (a) , (b) , (c) .
ShowHide solution
(a) : so cm.
(b) faces cm, the longest side of : the cosine rule. so
(adj. ∠s on a str. line)
(c) so cm.
(a) cm (b) (c) cm
Question 10
In , m, m and . Siti finds m (3 s.f.), and then so . Is she right?
ShowHide solution
so m, which is m to 3 s.f.
With the full value: so
She used the rounded , which gives : the rounding error in changed the last figure.
No: . She rounded before using it.
Question 11
A triangular field has sides m, m and m. Find its largest angle and its area.
ShowHide solution
The largest angle faces the longest side, m. so
Area, with the m and m sides and the angle between them: m (3 s.f.)
The largest angle is ; the area is m (3 s.f.).
Key Points
- A complete pair (a side and the angle opposite it; with two angles known, find the third first) means the sine rule; two sides and the included angle, or three sides, give none: the cosine rule first.
- Two angles and a side, or two sides and an angle not between them: the sine rule. Two sides and the included angle, or three sides: the cosine rule.
- After the cosine rule, use the sine rule only for an angle that cannot be obtuse (one not facing the longest side); otherwise the cosine rule again.
- Finish with the angle sum, then the area by with the angle between the two sides.
- With two triangles, solve first the one with three facts, for the side they share.
- Keep at least 4 significant figures, or the calculator's value, until the end; round only the answers.