Solving Quadratic Equations by Graphs
How to solve a quadratic equation from its graph: reading the roots to 1 decimal place and checking them with the formula, drawing the line or a suitable straight line , and counting the solutions.
Before you start
- In Secondary 2 you drew the graph of for from a table of values. It meets the -axis at and , the roots of , which factorises as .
- You also read for a given : a dashed line across meets a ∪-shaped curve twice, touches it once at its minimum point, or misses it.
- In lesson 1.3 you solved quadratic equations with the formula. Here the formula checks what the graph shows.
The Graphical Method
The roots of are integers, so they can also be found by factorising. Most quadratic equations do not factorise, but every one has a graph. Drawn carefully to scale, the graph shows the roots as the -coordinates of the points where the curve meets the -axis, whether they are integers or not.
A reading from a graph is an estimate, good to about 1 decimal place. Write it with , and check it with the formula of lesson 1.3: the two should agree to about .
Solving by drawing a graph
1. Make a table of values of for the range of given.
2. Plot every point to the scale given and join them with one smooth curve, drawn freehand through every point; do not join them with straight lines.
3. Read the -coordinates of the points where the curve meets the -axis, to 1 decimal place. These are the solutions.
How close is a reading?
A careful reading is good to within about one small square of the graph paper. On a scale of 2 cm to 1 unit, a small square of 2 mm is unit, so a reading may be about out, a little more where the curve crosses at a shallow angle.
Each answer on this page gives the reading, then the readings that are fair on the scale the question gives: " (accept to )".
Example 1: Roots that are not whole numbers
The table gives values of .
Draw the graph of for , using a scale of 2 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis. Use your graph to solve , and check your answers with the formula.
Solution
Plot the six points and join them with a smooth curve. Its minimum point lies halfway between and , which have the same value of , so round the bottom of the curve below there. Here each square is unit across and unit up; on graph paper, use the scale the question gives.
The curve meets the -axis between and , a little more than half a square left of : . On the right it meets it between and , just over half a square right of : .
Check with the formula: , , .
, so or , that is and to 2 decimal places. The readings agree.
(accept to ) or ( to )
The Line
One graph solves many equations. Every point on the line has , so where that line meets the curve , . The -axis is the line : the roots in Example 1 are one case of this.
If the equation is not yet in this form, add or subtract a number on both sides, or divide every term, until one side is exactly the expression of the curve you have drawn.
Solving
The solutions of are the -coordinates of the points where the curve meets the line .
Draw the line across the graph and read the -coordinate of each meeting point, to 1 decimal place.
Example 2: Three equations from one graph
The graph of for is drawn below, using a scale of 2 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis. Use it to solve
(a)
(b)
(c) .
Solution
Here each square is unit across and unit up; on graph paper, use the scale the question gives.
(a) The left side is already the curve. Draw the line .
Check with the formula: adding to both sides gives , so and or ✓
(b) Make the left side the curve: subtract from both sides, . Draw the line .
The line meets the curve where and . Check by factorising: ✓
(c) The curve has , not , so first divide every term by : . Then add to both sides, since : . Draw the line .
Check with the formula on : so or ✓
(a) (accept to ) or ( to )
(b) (accept to ) or ( to )
(c) (accept to ) or ( to )
Drawing a Suitable Straight Line
The equation has a different term from the curve , so no line will solve it. Make one side the curve anyway: the other side is then , and the straight line solves the equation.
Finding the line to draw
1. Write the equation with on one side. If its term is not the same as the curve's, divide (or multiply) every term so that it is.
2. Add to both sides whatever turns the equation's side into the curve's expression. The other side is the line: line (the curve's expression) (the equation's side).
3. Draw the line through three points of it worked out across the range, and read the -coordinates of the points where it meets the curve.
Example 3: A sloping line
Use the graph of in Example 2 to solve
(a)
(b) .
Solution
(a) The curve minus the equation: So add to both sides: that is, .
Draw through , and .
Check with the formula: so or ✓
(b) Divide every term by first: . The curve minus this: So
Draw through , and .
Check with the formula on : so or ✓
(a) (accept to ) or ( to )
(b) (accept to ) or ( to )
How Many Solutions?
Counting solutions
The number of solutions is the number of points where the line meets the curve.
A line that crosses the curve twice gives two solutions. A line that just touches the curve gives one solution (two equal roots). A line that misses the curve gives no real solutions.
A graph shows only the solutions inside the range of drawn. When a question asks how many solutions lie in that range, count only those; the equation itself may have others beyond the ends of the curve drawn.
Example 4: Two, one or none
Use the graph of in Example 2.
(a) Solve .
(b) Show that has no real solutions.
(c) For which value of does have exactly one solution? For which values of does it have two?
Solution
(a) Subtract from both sides: . (b) Subtract : . Draw and .
(a) The line touches the curve at its minimum point, : one solution, . Check: two equal roots ✓
(b) The line lies below the minimum point, so it never meets the curve: no value of makes . Check with the formula: the number under the square root, is negative, so the formula gives no real value of : no real solutions ✓
(c) Slide a line up and down the graph. Above the minimum point it crosses the curve twice; through the minimum point it touches it once; below it, it misses.
For the meeting points lie beyond the ends of the curve drawn, but the curve carries on upwards outside this range, so the equation still has two solutions. (The question asks about the equation, not only the range drawn.)
(a) (accept to : a touch is hard to place)
(b) The line does not meet the curve, so there are no real solutions.
(c) Exactly one solution when ; two solutions when .
A Graph in a Setting
In a setting the axes have names and units, and only the part of the curve that makes sense is drawn. Give each answer in words, with its unit.
Example 5: The height of a ball
A ball is kicked up from the ground. Its height, metres, after seconds is . The graph for is drawn below, using a scale of 4 cm to represent 1 second on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 2 m on the -axis.
(a) When is the ball 8 m above the ground?
(b) Does the ball ever reach a height of 12 m?
(c) When does it land?
Solution
Here each square is s across and m up.
(a) Draw the line . It meets the curve twice: on the way up and on the way down.
(b) Draw the line . The maximum point of the curve is , below the line, so they never meet.
Check (a) with the formula: gives , and or ✓
Check (b): for the number under the square root, is negative, so the formula gives no real value of : no real solutions ✓
(c) The ball lands when again: the curve meets the -axis at . Check: gives (when it is kicked) or ✓
(a) After about s (accept to ) and again after about s ( to ).
(b) No: its greatest height is m.
(c) After seconds ( to ).
Common Mistakes
- Writing the -coordinates of the meeting points. The solutions are the -coordinates.
- Drawing a line before one side of the equation is exactly the curve drawn. With the curve , must be halved first: the line is , not .
- Getting the line's signs the wrong way round. It is the curve's expression minus the equation's side: for , , not .
- Joining the points with straight lines, or making a sharp point at the bottom of the curve. Draw one smooth curve.
- Counting a touch as two solutions, or, when a question asks about the range drawn, counting meeting points outside it.
- Giving a reading as exact, or to 2 decimal places. A reading is an estimate to 1 decimal place, written with ; the formula gives the 2 decimal places.
Practice Questions
Use the graph given (or draw it on graph paper to the scale the question gives). A reading is fair within the range given after "accept". The questions get harder as you go.
Question 1
The graph of for is drawn below, using a scale of 2 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis.
(a) Use it to solve .
(b) Check your answers with the formula, to 2 decimal places.
ShowHide solution
(a) The curve meets the -axis a little past and a little before : and .
(b) , , . so or , that is and . The readings agree.
(a) (accept to ) or ( to )
(b) or (2 d.p.)
Question 2
The graph of for is drawn below, using a scale of 2 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis. Use it to solve
(a)
(b) .
ShowHide solution
(a) Read where the curve meets the -axis. (b) Add to both sides: ; draw the line .
Check (a) with the formula: multiply by , ; so or ✓
Check (b) by factorising: , so or ✓
(a) (accept to ) or ( to )
(b) (accept to ) or ( to )
Question 3
Use the graph of in Example 2 to solve
(a)
(b) .
ShowHide solution
(a) Add to both sides: . (b) Halve every term: ; subtract from both sides: .
(a) The line meets the curve at the two ends of the range drawn, and . Check: ✓
(b) The line is just above the minimum point and crosses the curve at a shallow angle, so these readings are the least sure. Check with the formula: so or ✓
(a) (accept to ) or ( to )
(b) (accept to ) or ( to )
Question 4
Write down the straight line you would draw on the graph of to solve each equation.
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
ShowHide solution
In each, the line is the curve's expression minus the equation's side (with on the other side).
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d) Halve first: . Then
(e) Write it as . Then
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
Question 5
By drawing a suitable straight line on the graph of in Example 2, solve . Check your answers with the formula.
ShowHide solution
so . Draw through , and .
Check: , , ; so or , that is and ✓
(accept to ) or ( to )
Question 6
The line is drawn on the graph of .
(a) Which equation, in its simplest form, do the -coordinates of the meeting points solve?
(b) How many times does the line meet the curve? Solve the equation.
ShowHide solution
(a) At a meeting point, Add to both sides: .
(b) The line touches the curve at one point, , where it crosses the -axis. has one solution, (two equal roots).
(a) (b) Once (it touches the curve); (accept to : a touch is hard to place).
Question 7
Use the graph of for in Question 2. How many solutions does have in this range when
(a) (b) (c) ?
ShowHide solution
(a) The maximum point of the curve is a little above (at , midway between and , which both give : so the line crosses it twice. Check: gives or , both in the range.
(b) The line is above the maximum point: no solution.
(c) The line crosses the right arm once, between and . The left arm ends at , above the line, so the second solution of the equation lies below , outside the range drawn.
(a) Two (b) None (c) One
Question 8
A rectangle has a perimeter of cm. When one side is cm, the other is cm and the area, cm², is . The graph for is drawn below, using a scale of 1 cm to represent 1 cm on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 2 cm² on the -axis.
(a) Find the values of that give an area of cm².
(b) Can the area be cm²? Explain.
ShowHide solution
Here each square is cm across and cm² up.
(a) The line meets the curve at and . Check: , or ✓. The two values give the same rectangle, about cm by cm, with its sides swapped.
(b) The maximum point of the curve is : the greatest area is cm², when the rectangle is a square of side cm. The line does not meet the curve. Check: for the number under the square root, is negative, so the formula gives no real value of : no real solutions ✓
(a) (accept to ) or ( to )
(b) No: the greatest area is cm².
Question 9
A stone is thrown upwards from a platform m above the ground. Its height above the ground, metres, after seconds is . The graph for is drawn below, using a scale of 4 cm to represent 1 second on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 1 m on the -axis.
(a) When is the stone m above the ground?
(b) When does it hit the ground?
ShowHide solution
Here each square is s across and m up.
(a) The line meets the drawn curve once, on the way down, at . Check: , or . The negative time is before the throw, so it is rejected; that part of the curve is not drawn.
(b) The curve meets the -axis at . Check: ✓
(a) After about s (accept to ).
(b) After seconds ( to ).
Question 10
Find the fault in each answer, and give the right line.
(a) To solve with the graph of , Ahmad drew the line .
(b) To solve with the same graph, Mei Ling subtracted from and, leaving out the and terms, drew the line .
ShowHide solution
(a) He subtracted the wrong way round: The line is the curve minus the equation:
(b) The terms are not the same, so the difference is , not a straight line. The line solves , that is , a different equation. Halve first: , so the line is (Example 2 (c)).
(a) The line is . (b) The equation must be halved first; the line is .
Question 11
(a) Complete the table of values for .
(b) Draw the graph of for , using a scale of 2 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis and 1 cm to represent 1 unit on the -axis.
(c) Use your graph to solve .
(d) By drawing a suitable straight line on your graph, solve .
ShowHide solution
(a) At : . At : At : .
(b), (c) Plot the points and join them with a smooth curve. Subtract from both sides of the equation: . Draw the line .
Check (c): , or ✓
(d) so . Draw through , and .
Check (d): , or ✓
(a) , ,
(b) The graph above.
(c) (accept to ) or ( to )
(d) (accept to ) or ( to )
Key Points
- The roots of are the -coordinates of the points where the curve meets the -axis.
- The solutions of are where the curve meets the line .
- To solve another equation, rearrange it so that one side is exactly the curve drawn; the other side, or , is the line to draw.
- Read solutions to 1 decimal place, write them with , and check them with the formula.
- Two meeting points give two solutions, a touch gives one, and a line that misses the curve means no real solutions. When a question asks about the range drawn, count only inside it.