Problems Involving Simultaneous Inequalities
How to list and count the integers, primes and other numbers that satisfy simultaneous inequalities, find the greatest and least values of expressions such as x − y, xy and x², and solve word problems with two conditions.
Before you start
In Secondary 2 you found the largest and smallest integer in the solution of one inequality: the largest integer in is 5, and in it is 3, never rounded to the nearest. In word problems, "at least" gives , "at most" and "not more than" give , and a whole-number answer is rounded down for the greatest number allowed and up for the least number needed.
In lesson 2.1 you solved simultaneous inequalities: solve each one, and the solution is where they overlap.
Example: a solved pair
Solve the simultaneous inequalities and .
Solution
The first: , so . The second: , so .
Listing and Counting Integers
The solution of simultaneous inequalities is often a stretch between two numbers, and only a few integers lie in it. To list them, find the smallest and the largest, then go along the number line from one to the other.
The integers in a solution between two numbers
The smallest integer: if the left end is an integer that is included (), it is the smallest. If it is an integer that is not included (), the smallest is the next integer to its right. If it is not an integer, the smallest is the first integer to its right.
The largest integer: the same at the right end, going to the left.
How many: from the integer to the integer , there are integers.
Example 1: Ends that are and are not included
List the integers that satisfy each of these, and say how many there are.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Solution
(a) is not included, so the smallest integer is . 3 is included, so it is the largest.
From to 3 there are integers.
(b) is included and 3 is not: the integers are to 2, and there are .
(c) Both ends are included: the integers are to 3, and there are .
(a) , 0, 1, 2, 3: five integers (b) , , 0, 1, 2: five integers (c) , , 0, 1, 2, 3: six integers
Example 2: Ends that are not integers
(a) List the integers that satisfy and , the pair solved above.
(b) Solve and list the integers that satisfy it.
Solution
(a) The solution is . The first integer to the right of is . is to the left of , so it is not a solution: , and is false.
(b) Split: gives . gives , so , that is .
The first integer to the right of is 3. 6 is not included, so the largest integer is 5.
Check : the three parts are 7, 10 and 12, and is true. Check : the parts are 4, 8 and 7, and is false.
(a) , , 0, 1, 2, 3: six integers (b) ; the integers are 3, 4 and 5.
Primes, Even Numbers and Other Kinds
A question may ask only for numbers of one kind: positive integers, even or odd numbers, prime numbers, perfect squares or multiples. List the integers in the solution first, then pick out the ones of that kind. Remember that 1 is not a prime number, and 2 is the only even prime.
Example 3: Numbers of a certain kind
satisfies . List
(a) the integers,
(b) the prime numbers,
(c) the even numbers,
(d) the perfect squares
that can be.
Solution
is in the middle part only, so add 1 to all three parts: . Divide all three by 2: .
(a) The first integer to the right of 2.5 is 3. 13 is not included, so the largest is 12.
(b) Of 3 to 12, the primes are 3, 5, 7 and 11. 9 is , so it is not prime.
(c) The even numbers are 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12.
(d) The perfect squares are and .
(a) 3, 4, 5, …, 12 (ten integers) (b) 3, 5, 7, 11 (c) 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 (d) 4, 9
Example 4: Counting without listing
(a) How many integers satisfy ?
(b) How many integers satisfy , and how many of them are even?
Solution
(a) Split: and .
The first: subtract 5 from both sides, . Divide both sides by , which reverses the sign: , which is .
The second: subtract 5 from both sides, . Divide both sides by , which reverses the sign: .
The integers run from to 3: .
(b) Divide all three parts by 3: . The integers run from 5 to 50: .
The even ones are 6, 8, 10, …, 50, that is to : .
(a) 7 integers (b) 46 integers, of which 23 are even
Greatest and Least Values of an Expression
When and each lie in a range, an expression in them, such as or , lies in a range too. Its greatest and least values come from the ends of the two ranges, but which ends depends on the expression.
Greatest and least values
Sum : the greatest value is the greatest plus the greatest ; the least is the least plus the least .
Difference : the greatest value is the greatest minus the least ; the least is the least minus the greatest . Taking away less leaves more.
Product : work out at the four pairs of ends (the "corners") and take the greatest and the least. With negative numbers, "greatest times greatest" is often wrong.
Square : if the range of includes 0, the least value is 0. If the range does not include 0, the least value is the square of the end nearer 0. The greatest is the square of the end further from 0.
Quotient : must not be 0. If is positive throughout, or negative throughout, try the four corners, as for . If can be any number on both sides of 0, has no greatest or least value: near 0 makes it as large or as small as you like. If is an integer on both sides of 0, try and with each end of .
Example 5: Sums and differences
and can be any numbers such that and .
(a) Find the range of values of and the range of values of .
(b) Find the greatest and least values of , and .
Solution
(a) Add 1 to all three parts: . Divide by 2: .
Add 2 to all three parts: . Divide by 3: .
(b) : the greatest is , and the least is .
: the greatest is the greatest minus the least , . The least is the least minus the greatest , .
: the greatest is , and the least is .
(a) and (b) : greatest 7, least ; : greatest 1, least ; : greatest 8, least
Example 6: Products, squares and quotients
With and , as in Example 5, find the greatest and least values of
(a) ,
(b) ,
(c) , if it has them.
Solution
(a) The corners: , , and . The least times the least is , but is less than that.
(b) The trap: squaring the ends gives and , and it is tempting to say that lies between 4 and 9. But can be 0, and ; can be 1, and . The range of includes 0, so the least value of is 0. The end further from 0 is , so the greatest is .
(c) can be any number from to 2, so it can be as close to 0 as we like, on either side ( itself has no meaning). Near 0 the quotient grows without end: and give , and gives .
(a) Greatest 10, least (b) Greatest 9, least 0 (c) No greatest or least value: can be as close to 0 as we like, on either side.
Example 7: Products of negative numbers
Given that and can be any numbers with and , find the greatest and least values of
(a) ,
(b) .
Solution
(a) The trap: the greatest times the greatest is , which is not the greatest value of . Try the corners: , , and .
Two negative numbers multiply to a positive one, so the greatest is . The least is .
(b) is negative throughout, so 0 is not in its range. Square the ends: and . The end further from 0, , gives the greatest.
(a) Greatest 12, least (b) Greatest 16, least 1
Integers or any numbers? A range with at an end has no greatest or least value at that end: allows , , , … but not , so has no least value. When a question says that and are integers, use the greatest and least integers in each range instead. Read which the question means, every time: it changes the answer.
Example 8: When x and y must be integers
and are integers, with and . Find the greatest and least values of
(a) ,
(b) ,
(c) , where .
Solution
The integers are , , 0, 1, 2 and , 2, 3, 4.
(a) The greatest is . The least is .
(b) The corners: , , and .
(c) Now is , , 1 or 2, on both sides of 0, so the corners are not enough. Here is positive throughout, so is greatest when is the positive integer nearest 0 and is greatest: . It is least when is the negative integer nearest 0 and is greatest: .
If could be any number in its range other than 0, would have no greatest value: and give 40, and gives 400.
(a) Greatest 1, least (b) Greatest 8, least (c) Greatest 4, least
Word Problems with Two Conditions
Many problems set two conditions at once: a budget and a minimum order, a mark that must be at least one number but below another. Each condition is one inequality, and the answer must satisfy both.
Solving a problem with two conditions
Step 1: Say what the letter stands for, with its unit.
Step 2: Write one inequality for each condition, choosing each sign from the words.
Step 3: Solve each, and combine them into one statement.
Step 4: Give the values the setting allows, such as whole numbers: round down at the upper end and up at the lower end. On the number line, draw the bound you found, before rounding. Check both ends and the numbers just outside them.
Step 5: Answer in a sentence, with the unit.
Example 9: A budget and a minimum order
A class committee is ordering class T-shirts at S$12 each, with a delivery charge of S$25 for the whole order. The supplier takes orders of at least 15 T-shirts, and the committee can spend at most S$400. How many T-shirts can the committee order?
Solution
Let be the number of T-shirts. The order costs dollars.
"At least 15 T-shirts": . "At most S$400": .
Subtract 25 from both sides: . Divide by 12: . is a whole number, so .
So . Check: 31 T-shirts cost dollars, within S$400; 32 would cost dollars. 14 T-shirts would be below the minimum order.
The committee can order any whole number of T-shirts from 15 to 31.
Example 10: A mark between two grades
Jia Hui's marks in three tests were 58, 71 and 66. Each test is marked out of 100, in whole marks. A grade B needs an average mark of at least 60 but less than 70. What marks in a fourth test would give her a grade B?
Solution
Let be her mark in the fourth test. The four marks add up to and their average is .
"At least 60 but less than 70":
is in the middle part only, so multiply all three parts by 4: . Subtract 195 from all three: .
The marks are whole numbers, so is 45 to 84. Check: with 45 the average is , a B; with 44 it is . With 84 it is , a B; with 85 it is , which is not less than 70.
Any mark from 45 to 84 in the fourth test gives Jia Hui a grade B.
Example 11: The cheapest of three plans
Three mobile phone plans charge as follows. Plan A: S$10 a month plus 10 cents for each minute of calls. Plan B: S$25 a month plus 4 cents for each minute. Plan C: S$40 a month with free calls. For what whole numbers of minutes of calls in a month is plan B the cheapest?
Solution
Let be the number of minutes of calls in a month. In dollars, plan A costs , plan B costs and plan C costs 40.
Plan B must be cheaper than plan A: Subtract and 10 from both sides: . Divide by 0.06: , which is .
Plan B must also be cheaper than plan C: . Subtract 25: . Divide by 0.04: .
So : whole minutes from 251 to 374. Check: at 250 minutes plans A and B both cost S$35, so B is not cheaper; at 251 minutes A costs S$35.10 and B S$35.04. At 374 minutes B costs S$39.96; at 375 minutes it costs S$40, the same as C.
Plan B is the cheapest for 251 to 374 minutes of calls a month.
Common Mistakes
- Counting an end that is not included. has the integers to 3: five of them, not six.
- Going the wrong way from a negative end that is not an integer. The smallest integer in is , not : is to the left of .
- Taking the wrong ends for a difference. The least value of is the least minus the greatest : for and it is , not .
- Squaring the ends when the range includes 0. For , does not lie between 4 and 9: gives 0, so the least value is 0.
- Multiplying the greatest values when there are negative numbers. For and , the greatest value of is , not . Try all four corners.
- Forgetting one of the two conditions. In Example 9 the budget alone allows up to 31 T-shirts, but the supplier also needs at least 15.
Practice
Work each question on paper before you open its solution. Answer each word problem in a sentence with its unit.
Question 1
List the integers that satisfy each of these, and say how many there are.
(a)
(b)
ShowHide solution
(a) is included and 1 is not, so the integers are to 0: .
(b) The first integer to the right of is , and 4 is included: .
(a) , , , , 0: five integers (b) , 0, 1, 2, 3, 4: six integers
Question 2
Solve the simultaneous inequalities and , and list the integers that satisfy both.
ShowHide solution
The first: subtract 4 from both sides, . Divide by 3: .
The second: add 7 to both sides, . Divide by 2: .
The integers run from to 5, the first integer to the left of 5.5.
; the integers are , , , 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 (nine of them).
Question 3
Solve Then find
(a) the smallest and the largest integer that satisfy it,
(b) the prime numbers that satisfy it.
ShowHide solution
Split: and .
The first: subtract and 8 from both sides, . Divide by 3: , which is .
The second: subtract and 8 from both sides, . Divide by 2: .
(a) is not included, so the smallest integer is . 6 is included, so it is the largest. Check : is true.
(b) The integers are to 6. The primes among them are 2, 3 and 5.
(a) Smallest , largest 6 (b) 2, 3, 5
Question 4
How many integers satisfy ? How many of them are multiples of 4?
ShowHide solution
Subtract 1 from all three parts: . Divide all three by 2: .
The integers run from 3 to 30: .
The multiples of 4 among them are 4, 8, …, 28, that is to : 7 of them.
28 integers, of which 7 are multiples of 4
Question 5
satisfies . Find
(a) the smallest integer that can be,
(b) the largest odd number that can be,
(c) the prime numbers that can be,
(d) how many integers satisfy the inequality.
ShowHide solution
Split: and .
The first: subtract 9 from both sides, . Divide by , which reverses the sign: , which is .
The second: subtract 9 from both sides, . Divide by , which reverses the sign: .
The integers are to 4. (a) . (b) 4 is even, so 3. (c) The primes from to 4 are 2 and 3. (d) .
(a) (b) 3 (c) 2 and 3 (d) 7 integers
Question 6
Given that and can be any numbers with and , find the greatest and least values of
(a) ,
(b) ,
(c) .
ShowHide solution
(a) Greatest ; least .
(b) Greatest: the greatest minus the least , . Least: the least minus the greatest , .
(c) The corners: , , and .
(a) Greatest 10, least 1 (b) Greatest 7, least (c) Greatest 24, least
Question 7
Given that and can be any numbers with and , find the greatest and least values of
(a) ,
(b) ,
(c) .
ShowHide solution
(a) The range of includes 0, so the least value of is 0. The end further from 0 is , so the greatest is 25.
(b) The corners: , , and .
(c) Greatest: the greatest minus the least , . Least: the least minus the greatest , .
(a) Greatest 25, least 0 (b) Greatest 10, least (c) Greatest 27, least
Question 8
Ahmad says that if can be any number with , the least value of is 1 and the greatest is 16. Is he right? Explain.
ShowHide solution
He squared the two ends: and . The greatest, 16, is right.
But the range of includes 0, and is less than 1. gives 0.25, which is less than 1 too.
No. The greatest value of is 16, but the least is 0, when .
Question 9
and are integers, with and . Find the greatest and least values of
(a) ,
(b) ,
(c) .
ShowHide solution
The integers are , 3, 4, 5 and , , , 0, 1.
(a) Greatest ; least .
(b) The corners: , , and .
(c) is positive throughout, so try the corners: , , and .
(a) Greatest 8, least 1 (b) Greatest 5, least (c) Greatest 0.5, least
Question 10
Mdm Rosnah is buying curry puffs for a family gathering. They are sold in boxes of 8 at S$6.50 a box. She needs at least 120 curry puffs, and she can spend at most S$120. How many boxes can she buy?
ShowHide solution
Let be the number of boxes. "At least 120 curry puffs": , so .
"At most S$120": , so , and as is a whole number, .
So . Check: 18 boxes cost S$117, and 19 would cost S$123.50. 15 boxes hold exactly 120 curry puffs.
Mdm Rosnah can buy 15, 16, 17 or 18 boxes.
Question 11
A goods lift can carry a load of at most 1200 kg. A worker of mass 68 kg takes sacks of rice up in the lift, each of mass 25 kg. To make a trip worthwhile, at least 20 sacks must go up each time. How many sacks can he take up in one trip?
ShowHide solution
Let be the number of sacks. "At least 20": .
The load is kilograms, and "at most 1200": . Subtract 68: . Divide by 25: , so .
Check: with 45 sacks the load is kg, within the limit; with 46 sacks it is 1218 kg.
He can take from 20 to 45 sacks in one trip.
Question 12
A class is going to the Science Centre. The bus costs S$300 and each pupil's ticket costs S$9, and the class fund has S$700 to pay for both. The bus has 40 seats for pupils, and the trip goes ahead only if more than 30 pupils go. How many pupils can go?
ShowHide solution
Let be the number of pupils. There are three conditions.
The fund: , so and , and as is a whole number, .
The seats: . The trip: .
All three overlap from 30 (not included) to 40. Check: 40 pupils cost dollars, within S$700.
From 31 to 40 pupils can go.
Key Points
- To list the integers in a solution, find the smallest and the largest. An end that is not included, or is not an integer, moves you to the next integer inwards.
- From the integer to the integer there are integers.
- For numbers of one kind (primes, even numbers, perfect squares, multiples), list the integers first, then pick them out.
- The greatest value of is the greatest minus the least ; the least is the least minus the greatest .
- For , and for when keeps one sign, try the four corners. If the range of includes 0, the least value of is 0.
- Say whether and are integers or any numbers in their ranges: it changes the answer.
- In a word problem, write one inequality for each condition, combine them, and give the values the setting allows in a sentence.