Hire Purchase
Buying now and paying in monthly instalments: the deposit, flat-rate interest on the outstanding balance, the instalment, the hire purchase price against the cash price, finding the rate or the deposit, and why a flat rate costs more than it seems.
Before you start
In Secondary 3 you found simple interest with , where is the principal in dollars, the rate of interest is per annum, and is the time in years: $4000 at 2.5% per annum for 3 years earns dollars. A time in months is written in years first: 9 months is of a year.
Hire purchase uses the same formula. In this lesson money is in Singapore dollars, to the nearest cent. The prices and rates are examples, not any shop’s or bank’s real terms: rates change, so a question always gives the rate to use.
Two Ways to Pay
A shop sells a television for $2400. A family can pay the cash price, $2400, all at once. Or they can buy it on hire purchase: they pay part of the price now, the deposit (also called the down payment), take the television home, and pay the rest in monthly instalments. The television belongs to the seller (or the finance company) until the last instalment is paid: until then the family is hiring it.
The part of the cash price still owed after the deposit is the outstanding balance. The seller (or a finance company) is lending the family that money, so it charges interest on it. Each monthly instalment pays back part of the balance and part of the interest, and all the instalments are the same (the last may differ by a few cents of rounding, as in Example 4).
The words of hire purchase
Outstanding balance cash price deposit
Total of the instalments outstanding balance interest
Monthly instalment total of the instalments number of months
Hire purchase price deposit total of the instalments
Amount paid in addition to the cash price hire purchase price cash price
Flat-Rate Interest on the Outstanding Balance
Hire purchase interest is charged at a flat rate per annum: it is simple interest on the whole outstanding balance, for the whole time of the instalments. It is worked out once, at the start, with , where is the outstanding balance, not the cash price.
Flat-rate interest
Interest where the flat rate is per annum and is the number of years of instalments.
The time is in years: 24 months is 2 years, 30 months is 2.5 years, 9 months is year.
Example 1: A Television on Hire Purchase
A television has a cash price of $2400. On hire purchase it needs a deposit of 20% of the cash price and 24 monthly instalments, with interest at a flat rate of 5% per annum. Find (a) the monthly instalment, (b) the hire purchase price, (c) how much more than the cash price the family pays.
Solution
Deposit dollars.
Outstanding balance dollars.
24 months is 2 years, so the interest dollars.
Total of the instalments dollars.
(a) Monthly instalment dollars.
(b) Hire purchase price dollars.
(c) dollars. The amount paid in addition is the interest, because the deposit and the balance together are the cash price.
The two ways to pay for the television
| Cash | |
|---|---|
| Paid now | $2400 |
| Paid later | — |
| Total | $2400 |
| Hire purchase | |
|---|---|
| Paid now | $480 deposit |
| Paid later | 24 × $88 = $2112 |
| Total | $2592 |
(a) The monthly instalment is $88. (b) The hire purchase price is $2592. (c) The family pays $192 more than the cash price.
Working Back: the Rate and the Deposit
An advertisement often gives the deposit and the instalments but not the rate. The interest is what is paid on top of the balance, so the rate can be found from , as in Secondary 3.
Example 2: Cash or Instalments? Finding the Rate
A sofa costs $1850 in cash, or $350 down and 18 monthly instalments of $90. (a) How much more does the sofa cost on instalments? Give this as a percentage of the cash price. (b) Find the flat rate of interest per annum.
Solution
(a) Hire purchase price dollars.
Amount paid in addition dollars, and which is 6.49% to 3 significant figures.
(b) Outstanding balance dollars. The instalments total $1620, so the interest is dollars.
18 months is 1.5 years. so
(a) $120 more, which is 6.49% of the cash price. (b) The flat rate is , about 5.33%, per annum.
To find the deposit from the instalments, work back to the balance. At 4% per annum for 1 year the interest is 4% of the balance, so the total of the instalments is 104% of the balance: . For years at the total is
Example 3: Finding the Deposit
A laptop costs $1600 in cash. On hire purchase it is a deposit and 12 monthly instalments of $119.60, with interest at a flat rate of 4% per annum. Find the deposit.
Solution
Total of the instalments dollars.
12 months is 1 year, so the total is the balance plus 4% of it:
Balance dollars.
Deposit dollars.
Check: interest and
The deposit is $220.
Loans Repaid in Monthly Instalments
In Singapore a car is often bought with a car loan, repaid in equal monthly instalments over several years. Many car loans charge interest at a flat rate on the amount borrowed, worked out just as for hire purchase.
Example 4: A Car Loan
A family borrows $72 000 to buy a car. The loan is repaid in monthly instalments over 7 years, at a flat rate of 2.78% per annum (an example rate, not a bank’s quote). Find the interest and the monthly instalment.
Solution
Interest dollars.
Total to repay dollars.
7 years is months, so the instalment which is $1023.94 to the nearest cent.
Because the instalment is rounded, 84 instalments of $1023.94 come to 24 cents less than the total; the lender adds the few cents to the last instalment.
The interest is $14 011.20 and the monthly instalment is $1023.94.
Why a Flat Rate Costs More Than It Seems
Example 5: Interest on Money Already Paid Back
In Example 1 the family pays $192 interest at a flat rate of 5% per annum on the balance of $1920 for 2 years. Explain why the loan really costs more than 5% a year.
Solution
Each instalment of $88 pays back dollars of the balance (and $8 of interest). After 12 instalments the family has paid back half of the $1920, yet the interest was worked out on all of it, for the whole 2 years.
On average over the 24 months they owe about $1000 (from $1920 in the first month down to $80 in the last: Paying $192 for the use of about $1000 for 2 years is about a year: nearly twice the 5% flat rate.
The flat rate charges interest on the whole balance for the whole time, even on money already paid back, so the true cost of the loan is nearly twice the 5% it seems to be.
So why buy on hire purchase?
A family may not have the cash price now, or may want to keep its savings for an emergency. Hire purchase lets them use the item at once and spread the cost. Before they sign, they should compare the hire purchase price with the cash price, and know that the flat rate is not what the loan really costs.
Common Mistakes
- Working out the interest on the cash price. Interest is charged on the outstanding balance, the cash price less the deposit.
- Putting months in for : 24 months is , not .
- Leaving the deposit out of the hire purchase price. Hire purchase price deposit all the instalments.
- Dividing the balance alone by the number of months. The instalments pay back the balance and the interest.
- Rounding the instalment and then multiplying it back up to find the total: work out the total first, then divide.
Practice
Give money to the nearest cent. A rate is a flat rate per annum on the outstanding balance unless the question says otherwise. The prices and rates are examples.
Question 1
A refrigerator has a cash price of $1800. On hire purchase it needs a deposit of 10% and 12 monthly instalments, at a flat rate of 3% per annum. Find the monthly instalment and the hire purchase price.
ShowHide solution
Deposit balance dollars.
Interest dollars.
Total of the instalments so each instalment is dollars.
Hire purchase price dollars.
Monthly instalment $139.05; hire purchase price $1848.60
Question 2
A washing machine costs $960 in cash, or a deposit of $160 and 15 monthly instalments of $56. Find (a) the hire purchase price, (b) how much more it costs on hire purchase, (c) this amount as a percentage of the cash price.
ShowHide solution
(a) dollars.
(b) dollars.
(c) which is 4.17% to 3 significant figures.
(a) $1000 (b) $40 (c) 4.17%
Question 3
A motorcycle costs $6400 in cash. On hire purchase it needs a deposit of 25% and 30 monthly instalments, at a flat rate of 3.5% per annum. Find the monthly instalment and the amount paid in addition to the cash price.
ShowHide solution
Deposit balance dollars.
30 months is years. Interest dollars.
Instalment dollars.
The amount paid in addition is the interest: hire purchase price and dollars.
Monthly instalment $174; $420 more than the cash price
Question 4
A bicycle costs $1200 in cash, or a deposit of $200 and 24 monthly instalments of $45. Find the flat rate of interest per annum.
ShowHide solution
Balance dollars. Total of the instalments dollars, so the interest is dollars.
24 months is 2 years: so .
4% per annum
Question 5
A camera costs $2000 in cash. On hire purchase it is a deposit and 18 monthly instalments of $109, at a flat rate of 6% per annum. Find the deposit.
ShowHide solution
Total of the instalments dollars.
18 months is 1.5 years, so the interest is of the balance, and
Balance dollars, so the deposit is dollars.
Check: and
The deposit is $200.
Question 6
A laptop costs $1500 in cash at two shops. Shop P asks for a deposit of 20% and 12 monthly instalments at a flat rate of 6% per annum. Shop Q asks for no deposit and 24 monthly instalments at a flat rate of 4% per annum. (a) Find the monthly instalment and the total paid at each shop. (b) Which shop costs less in total, and by how much? (c) Give one reason why a buyer might still choose the other shop.
The two shops’ terms (examples)
| Shop P | |
|---|---|
| Deposit | 20% |
| Instalments | 12 monthly |
| Flat rate | 6% per annum |
| Shop Q | |
|---|---|
| Deposit | none |
| Instalments | 24 monthly |
| Flat rate | 4% per annum |
ShowHide solution
(a) Shop P: deposit balance ; interest instalment total paid dollars.
Shop Q: balance ; interest instalment total paid dollars.
(b) , so Shop P costs $48 less, although its rate is higher: it lends less money for a shorter time.
(c) Shop Q needs no deposit and its instalment, $67.50, is much smaller than $106, so a buyer with little cash to spare each month might choose it.
(a) P: $106 a month, $1572 in total; Q: $67.50 a month, $1620 in total. (b) Shop P, by $48. (c) For example: Shop Q needs no deposit and has smaller instalments.
Question 7
A phone costs $2100 in cash, or a deposit of $300 and 9 monthly instalments, at a flat rate of 4% per annum. Find the monthly instalment.
ShowHide solution
Balance dollars.
9 months is year. Interest dollars.
Instalment dollars.
Putting would give interest of $648, more than a third of the balance: a sign that months have been used as years.
The monthly instalment is $206.
Question 8
Wei Jie works out the instalment for a scooter with a cash price of $3000, a deposit of 20%, and 24 monthly instalments at a flat rate of 5% per annum. He writes: interest instalment Find his mistake and the correct instalment.
ShowHide solution
He worked out the interest on the cash price, $3000. Interest is charged only on the outstanding balance, dollars.
Interest dollars, so the instalment is dollars.
He charged interest on the cash price instead of the balance. The instalment is $110.
Question 9
Mr and Mrs Ong borrow $90 000 for a car at a flat rate of 2.48% per annum. Find the monthly instalment if they repay over (a) 5 years, (b) 7 years. (c) How much more interest do they pay over 7 years than over 5?
ShowHide solution
(a) Interest total ; instalment dollars.
(b) Interest total ; instalment which is $1257.43.
(c) dollars. The longer loan has smaller instalments but costs more interest.
(a) $1686 (b) $1257.43 (c) $4464 more
Question 10
In Question 1 the refrigerator’s balance of $1620 is paid back over 12 months with $48.60 interest, at a flat rate of 3% per annum. About what yearly rate is the family really paying for the money it owes? Explain in a sentence or two.
ShowHide solution
The balance is paid back at dollars a month, so the family owes $1620 in the first month and $135 in the last. On average over the 12 months it owes about dollars.
Paying $48.60 for the use of about $877.50 for one year is about about 5.5% a year.
About 5.5% a year (accept 5% to 6%), nearly twice the 3% flat rate, because the interest is charged on the whole balance for the whole year even as it is paid back.
Key Points
- Outstanding balance cash price deposit.
- Flat-rate interest on the whole balance for the whole time, with in years.
- Monthly instalment (balance interest) number of months.
- Hire purchase price deposit total of the instalments; it is more than the cash price by the interest.
- Work back through the same formulas to find the rate, the balance or the deposit.
- A flat rate charges interest on money already paid back, so the loan really costs nearly twice the flat rate.