Possibility Diagrams
Listing every outcome of a two-stage experiment in a possibility diagram, as a table or as a grid of dots: two dice with their sum, product or difference, a coin and a die, two spinners, and counting the favourable cells.
What You Should Already Know
- From Secondary 2: the sample space of an experiment is the collection of all its possible outcomes, listed between braces. When a fair die is rolled, the sample space is : 6 outcomes.
- From Secondary 2: if all the possible outcomes are equally likely, For a fair die, 2, 4 and 6 are favourable to "an even number", so
- The formula holds only when the outcomes are equally likely. Treat a coin or a die as fair, and an object as taken at random, only when the question says so.
Experiments in Two Stages
Many experiments happen in two stages: two coins are tossed, two dice are rolled, a coin is tossed and a die is rolled, or two spinners are spun. An outcome of the whole experiment is then a pair: one outcome of the first stage together with one outcome of the second.
Keep the two stages apart by thinking of the objects as a first and a second (or a 10-cent coin and a 50-cent coin), even when they look the same. Then HT, a head on the first coin and a tail on the second, and TH are two different outcomes.
Example 1: Two coins
A fair 10-cent coin and a fair 50-cent coin are tossed. (a) Write down the sample space. Find the probability of getting (b) exactly one head; (c) two heads.
Solution
(a) Write the 10-cent coin first. It shows H or T, and with each of these the 50-cent coin shows H or T.
Sample space : outcomes.
Each coin is fair and neither coin affects the other, so the 4 outcomes are equally likely.
(b) Exactly one head: HT and TH, 2 favourable outcomes.
(c) Two heads: HH only.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Why not one chance in three?
It is tempting to list the results as "two heads, one head, no heads" and give each the probability . These three results are not equally likely: "one head" happens in two ways, HT and TH, while "two heads" happens in one way. Only a list of equally likely outcomes may be used with the formula.
The Possibility Diagram
Two dice give 36 pairs, and a list of them in braces is long and easy to get wrong. A possibility diagram sets the pairs out in a grid, so that none is missed and none is written twice.
Possibility diagram
A possibility diagram shows every outcome of an experiment in two stages. The outcomes of the first stage go across the top and the outcomes of the second stage down the side; each cell is the outcome made by its column and its row.
Number of outcomes (outcomes of the first stage) (outcomes of the second stage).
It may be drawn as a table, each cell holding its outcome (or the sum, product or difference of its two numbers), or as a grid of dots on two axes, a dot for each outcome.
If the outcomes of each stage are equally likely and one stage does not affect the other, the cells are equally likely, and
Example 2: Two dice, a table of outcomes
Two fair dice, one red and one blue, are rolled. (a) Draw a possibility diagram of all the outcomes and state how many there are. Find the probability that (b) the two dice show the same number; (c) both numbers are odd.
Solution
(a) Write the red die's numbers across the top and the blue die's down the side. Each cell is a pair, the red die's number first.
There are outcomes. The dice are fair and are rolled separately, so the 36 outcomes are equally likely.
(b) The same number on both dice: (1, 1), (2, 2), …, (6, 6), the 6 shaded cells on the diagonal.
(c) Both odd: the red die shows 1, 3 or 5 and so does the blue die. These are the ringed cells where the columns 1, 3 and 5 meet the rows 1, 3 and 5: cells.
(a) 36 outcomes; (b) ; (c) .
Sums, Products and Differences
Often only a number made from the two outcomes matters, such as the total score of two dice. Write that number in each cell. The diagram is still made of the 36 equally likely outcomes; only what is written in the cells has changed.
Example 3: The sum of two dice
Two fair dice are rolled and the numbers shown are added. (a) Draw a possibility diagram of the sum. Find the probability that the sum is (b) 7; (c) 9; (d) a prime number.
Solution
(a) The first die's numbers go across the top and the second die's down the side; each cell holds the sum of its column and its row.
There are 36 equally likely outcomes.
(b) The 6 shaded cells have a sum of 7: (1, 6), (2, 5), (3, 4), (4, 3), (5, 2) and (6, 1), the first die's number first.
(c) The 4 ringed cells have a sum of 9: (3, 6), (4, 5), (5, 4) and (6, 3).
(d) The sums run from 2 to 12; the prime ones are 2, 3, 5, 7 and 11. Count their cells in the diagram:
(b) ; (c) ; (d) .
Why not 1 chance in 11?
The sum of two dice is one of the 11 numbers 2, 3, 4, …, 12. Giving a sum of 7 the probability treats these 11 sums as equally likely, and they are not: a sum of 2 comes from one cell, (1, 1), and a sum of 7 from six. Down the diagonals of the diagram the sums 2, 3, …, 12 fill 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 cells.
The formula needs equally likely outcomes, and those are the 36 cells, not the 11 sums. That is why the diagram lists 36 cells:
Example 4: The product of two dice
Two fair dice are rolled and the numbers shown are multiplied. Find the probability that the product is (a) an odd number; (b) 12 or more; (c) 6.
Solution
Draw the possibility diagram with the product in each cell: 36 equally likely outcomes.
(a) A product is odd only when both numbers are odd, so the shaded cells are where the columns 1, 3, 5 meet the rows 1, 3, 5: 9 cells.
(b) Count the ringed cells, row by row from the top:
(c) A product of 6: (1, 6), (6, 1), (2, 3) and (3, 2), 4 cells.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Example 5: The difference of two dice
Two fair dice are rolled. The score is the larger number less the smaller, or 0 when the numbers are the same. (a) Draw a possibility diagram of the score. (b) Find the probability that the score is 2. (c) Which score is the most likely? Find its probability.
Solution
(a) Each cell holds the larger number less the smaller.
(b) The 8 shaded cells have a score of 2.
(c) Count the cells for each score: 0 has 6, 1 has 10 (ringed), 2 has 8, 3 has 6, 4 has 4 and 5 has 2. Check:
The most likely score is 1, with
(b) ; (c) a score of 1, with probability .
A Grid of Dots
A possibility diagram may also be drawn as dots on two axes: the first stage along the horizontal axis, the second up the vertical axis, and a dot at each outcome. It is quick to draw, and the favourable outcomes are picked out by shading or ringing their dots.
Read a dot as you read a point's coordinates: the dot above 5 and level with 2 is the outcome (5, 2), a 5 on the first die and a 2 on the second.
Example 6: Two dice as dots
Two fair dice are rolled. Draw a possibility diagram of dots and use it to find the probability that (a) the number on the first die is larger than the number on the second; (b) both numbers are even; (c) the sum of the numbers is 4 or less.
Solution
The first die is along the horizontal axis and the second up the vertical axis: 36 equally likely dots.
(a) The 6 dots on the diagonal from (1, 1) to (6, 6) have the same number twice. The other 30 dots are split evenly by the diagonal: below it the first number is larger, above it the second is. So 15 dots are shaded.
(b) Both even: 2, 4 or 6 on each die, the ringed dots.
(c) A sum of 4 or less: (1, 1), (1, 2), (2, 1), (1, 3), (2, 2) and (3, 1), the 6 dots in the bottom left corner.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Stages with Different Outcomes
The two stages need not have the same outcomes. A coin has 2 outcomes and a die 6, so a coin and a die give outcomes; a spinner of 3 equal sectors and a spinner of 4 give . The diagram is then a rectangle, not a square.
Example 7: A coin and a die
A fair coin is tossed and a fair die is rolled. (a) Draw a possibility diagram and write down the sample space. Find the probability of getting (b) a head and an even number; (c) a tail and a number greater than 4.
Solution
(a) The coin's H and T go across the top and the die's 1 to 6 down the side. Each cell joins the two: H3 is a head with a 3.
Sample space equally likely outcomes.
(b) A head and an even number: H2, H4 and H6, the 3 shaded cells. .
(c) A tail and a number greater than 4: T5 and T6, the 2 ringed cells. .
(b) ; (c) .
Example 8: Two spinners
Spinner A has three equal sectors numbered 1, 2 and 3. Spinner B has four equal sectors numbered 1, 2, 3 and 4. Both spinners are spun and the two numbers are added to give a total. Find the probability that the total is (a) 5 or more; (b) a prime number.
Solution
Spinner A's numbers go across the top and spinner B's down the side; each cell holds the total. The sectors of each spinner are equal, so the cells are equally likely.
(a) The totals 5, 6 and 7 fill the 6 shaded cells.
(b) The prime totals are 2, 3, 5 and 7 (4 and 6 are not prime). They fill ringed cells.
(a) ; (b) .
When the Outcomes Are Not Equally Likely
A possibility diagram finds a probability by counting cells, so every cell must be as likely as every other. On a spinner with unequal sectors the colours are not equally likely (Secondary 2: the probability of a sector is its angle ). Split the larger sectors into equal parts first, as Secondary 2 told identical balls apart as , , …, and the parts are equally likely.
The next lesson's tree diagram deals with such stages without any splitting.
Example 9: A spinner with unequal sectors
The spinner below has a red sector of , a blue sector of and a green sector of . It is spun once and a fair coin is tossed. Find the probability of getting red and a head.
Solution
Red, blue and green are not equally likely: red takes half of the circle. A diagram of the 3 colours with H and T would have 6 cells that are not equally likely, and would give the wrong answer .
Split the red sector into two sectors of , and . The spinner now has 4 equal sectors, , , B and G, which are equally likely.
There are equally likely outcomes, and 2 of them are red with a head.
Common Mistakes
- Treating the 11 sums of two dice, or the three results "two heads, one head, no heads" of two coins, as equally likely. Count the equally likely cells: not .
- Counting (2, 5) and (5, 2) as one outcome. A 2 on the first die with a 5 on the second is a different cell from a 5 on the first with a 2 on the second.
- Counting a double twice: (3, 3) is one cell.
- Leaving out a row or a column. Check the number of cells: for a coin and a die, for two dice.
- Drawing a spinner with unequal sectors as if its colours were equally likely. Split it into equal sectors first.
Practice
Try each question first, then open the solution to check your working.
Question 1
A fair coin is tossed and the spinner below, with four equal sectors coloured red, blue, green and yellow, is spun. (a) Draw a possibility diagram and state the number of outcomes. Find the probability of getting (b) a head; (c) a tail with red or blue.
ShowHide solution
(a) The coin across the top, the spinner down the side.
There are outcomes, equally likely as the coin is fair and the sectors are equal.
(b) The column under H has 4 cells.
(c) (T, Red) and (T, Blue): 2 cells. .
(a) 8 outcomes; (b) ; (c) .
Question 2
The possibility diagram below shows the sum of the numbers when two fair dice are rolled. Five of the sums are written as letters. (a) Find the values of , , , and . Find the probability that the sum is (b) 6; (c) less than 6.
ShowHide solution
(a) Each cell is its column's number plus its row's number.
, , , , .
(b) The sum is 6 in 5 cells: (1, 5), (2, 4), (3, 3), (4, 2), (5, 1).
(c) The sums 2, 3, 4 and 5 fill cells.
(a) , , , , ; (b) ; (c) .
Question 3
Two fair dice are rolled. Using a possibility diagram of the sum, find the probability that the sum is (a) 8; (b) a multiple of 3; (c) greater than 12.
ShowHide solution
Draw the diagram of sums as in Example 3: 36 equally likely cells.
(a) A sum of 8: (2, 6), (3, 5), (4, 4), (5, 3), (6, 2), 5 cells.
(b) The multiples of 3 between 2 and 12 are 3, 6, 9 and 12. They fill cells. .
(c) The largest sum is , so no cell is greater than 12. : the event is impossible.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Question 4
Two fair dice are rolled and the numbers shown are multiplied. Find the probability that the product is (a) an even number; (b) a multiple of 5; (c) a perfect square.
ShowHide solution
Use the diagram of products of Example 4: 36 equally likely cells.
(a) The product is odd in 9 cells (both numbers odd), so it is even in .
(b) A product is a multiple of 5 only when a die shows 5: the 6 cells of the column under 5, and the 5 other cells of the row beside 5 ((5, 5) is already counted). That is cells. .
(c) The perfect squares that appear are 1, 4, 9, 16, 25 and 36: (1, 1); (1, 4), (4, 1), (2, 2); (3, 3); (4, 4); (5, 5); (6, 6). That is 8 cells. .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Question 5
Two fair dice are rolled. The score is the larger number less the smaller (0 when they are the same). Find the probability that the score is (a) 0; (b) 3 or more.
ShowHide solution
Use the diagram of differences of Example 5: 36 equally likely cells.
(a) A score of 0 means the same number twice: the 6 doubles.
(b) Scores of 3, 4 and 5 fill cells.
(a) ; (b) .
Question 6
Two fair spinners each have four equal sectors numbered 1, 2, 3 and 4. Both are spun, and the score is the larger of the two numbers (the number itself if they are the same). (a) Draw a possibility diagram of the score. (b) Find the probability that the score is 4. (c) Find the probability that the score is 1. (d) Which score is the most likely?
ShowHide solution
(a) The first spinner across the top, the second down the side; each cell holds the larger of its two numbers.
There are equally likely cells.
(b) A score of 4 fills the last column, 4 cells, and the 3 other cells of the last row: cells.
(c) A score of 1 needs 1 on both spinners: 1 cell.
(d) The scores 1, 2, 3 and 4 fill 1, 3, 5 and 7 cells. The most likely score is 4.
(b) ; (c) ; (d) 4.
Question 7
In a game at a school carnival, a fair coin is tossed and a fair die is rolled. A player wins a prize if the coin shows a head and the die shows a number greater than 4, or if the coin shows a tail and the die shows a 1. Find the probability that a player wins a prize.
ShowHide solution
Use the coin-and-die diagram of Example 7: 12 equally likely outcomes, H1 to T6.
Winning outcomes: H5, H6 and T1, 3 cells.
The probability of winning a prize is .
Question 8
Wei Ling says: "When two dice are rolled, the sum is one of 2, 3, 4, …, 12. There are 11 possible sums, so the probability of a sum of 12 is ." Explain her mistake and find the correct probability for two fair dice.
ShowHide solution
The formula needs equally likely outcomes, and the 11 sums are not equally likely: a sum of 7 can happen in 6 ways and a sum of 12 in only 1.
The equally likely outcomes are the 36 cells of the possibility diagram. A sum of 12 needs a 6 on both dice: 1 cell.
The 11 sums are not equally likely; counting the 36 equally likely cells,
Question 9
A two-digit number is made by spinning two fair spinners. Spinner A, with three equal sectors numbered 1, 2 and 3, gives the tens digit; spinner B, with four equal sectors numbered 1, 2, 3 and 4, gives the units digit. Find the probability that the number is (a) greater than 20; (b) a prime number.
ShowHide solution
Spinner A across the top, spinner B down the side; each cell joins the tens digit and the units digit.
There are equally likely numbers: 11 to 14, 21 to 24 and 31 to 34.
(a) Greater than 20: the 8 numbers in the columns under 2 and 3. .
(b) Check each number for factors: 11, 13, 23 and 31 are prime; 12, 14, 22, 24, 32 and 34 are even; and . So 4 cells.
(a) ; (b) .
Question 10
Box A holds three cards numbered 2, 3 and 5. Box B holds four cards numbered 1, 4, 6 and 8. Siti takes a card at random from box A and Jun Wei takes a card at random from box B. The player with the larger number wins. (a) Draw a possibility diagram showing who wins for each outcome. (b) Who is more likely to win? Give the probability that each player wins.
ShowHide solution
(a) Box A across the top, box B down the side; each cell names the winner, S for Siti or J for Jun Wei. No number is in both boxes, so there is never a tie.
(b) The cards are taken at random, so the cells are equally likely. Siti wins in 4 cells (her 2, 3 or 5 against a 1, and her 5 against a 4); Jun Wei wins in the other 8.
and
Jun Wei is more likely to win: and
Question 11
A spinner has a red sector of , a blue sector of and a green sector of . It is spun once and a fair coin is tossed. By splitting the spinner into equal sectors, find the probability of getting (a) red and a head; (b) green and a tail.
ShowHide solution
The colours are not equally likely. The angles 180°, 120° and 60° are all multiples of , so split the spinner into 6 equal sectors of : 3 red (, , ), 2 blue (, ) and 1 green (G).
With the coin, there are equally likely outcomes.
(a) Red and a head: , or with H, 3 cells. .
(b) Green and a tail: G with T, 1 cell. .
(a) ; (b) .
Question 12
Two fair dice are rolled. The probability that the sum of the numbers is is . Find the two possible values of .
ShowHide solution
, so the sum must fill exactly 4 of the 36 cells.
The sums 2, 3, …, 12 fill 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 cells. A sum of 5 fills 4 cells, (1, 4), (2, 3), (3, 2), (4, 1), and so does a sum of 9, (3, 6), (4, 5), (5, 4), (6, 3).
or .
Key Points
- An outcome of a two-stage experiment is a pair: one outcome of each stage. A possibility diagram shows them all, the first stage across the top and the second down the side.
- Number of outcomes (outcomes of the first stage) (outcomes of the second): for two dice, for a coin and a die.
- A cell may hold the pair, or the sum, product or difference of its two numbers; a dot diagram puts a dot at each outcome.
- When the cells are equally likely,
- The 36 cells of two dice are equally likely; the 11 sums are not.
- Split a spinner with unequal sectors into equal sectors before drawing its possibility diagram.