Sine and Cosine of Obtuse Angles
Give sine and cosine a meaning for angles between and , see why and and find an angle from its sine or its cosine.
Before you start
- In Secondary 2 you met the ratios of an acute angle in a right-angled triangle: and (SOH-CAH-TOA).
- The calculator, in degree mode, gives their values, and and undo them: for example (3 decimal places), and (1 decimal place).
Obtuse Angles
An obtuse angle is between and . A triangle can have one: a triangle with angles , and , for example. The sine rule and the cosine rule (lessons 6.3 to 6.6) work in any triangle, so they need the sine and cosine of an obtuse angle too.
But an obtuse angle is never an angle of a right-angled triangle (with the right angle, its angles would add up to more than ). So "opposite over hypotenuse" cannot say what its sine is. This lesson gives sine and cosine a meaning for every angle from to that agrees with Secondary 2's for acute angles.
Each obtuse angle goes with the acute angle : the two are supplementary (they add up to ), like two angles on a straight line. For it is
The sine and cosine of turn out to be tied to those of . A semicircle shows how.
Sine and Cosine on a Semicircle
Draw a semicircle of radius unit about a point on a horizontal line. Turn a radius anticlockwise from the right-hand end of the line through an angle , and draw the perpendicular from to the line.
When is acute, is right-angled at with hypotenuse . So and . The sine is the height of above the line, and the cosine is how far is across from .
Sine and cosine of any angle from 0° to 180°
Turn the radius of a semicircle of radius through the angle , from the right-hand end of its line. Then
is the height of above the line;
is the distance of across from : positive when is to the right of , negative when it is to the left.
For an acute angle these are the Secondary 2 ratios. The calculator uses the same meaning for every angle.
At , is at the top, straight above : and . Past , is still above the line but now to the left of . So the sine of an obtuse angle is positive and its cosine is negative.
An Obtuse Angle and Its Acute Angle
Take an acute angle and mark two points on the semicircle: at the angle from the right-hand end, and at the angle from the left-hand end. Then has turned through from the right-hand end.
The right-angled triangles and have the same angles and the same hypotenuse, , so they are the same size: and . The two points are at the same height, and the same distance across from , but is to the right of and to the left.
Same height: the sines are equal. Opposite sides of : the cosines are equal in size and opposite in sign.
Sine and cosine of an obtuse angle
An obtuse angle has the same sine as the acute angle that makes with it, and the negative of its cosine.
The calculator gives these values directly. The two rules let you check them. The area formula and the sine rule (lessons 6.2 to 6.4) use the sine of an obtuse angle, and lesson 6.4 depends on the first rule when the sine rule gives two possible angles. Only sine and cosine are needed for obtuse angles in this course: the sine rule, the cosine rule and the area of a triangle use no tangent.
Example 1: The calculator, checked by the rules
Use a calculator to find and , correct to 3 decimal places. Check each with the rules.
Solution
Key sin 140 =: , so (3 d.p.).
Check: and , the same, as says.
Key cos 140 =: , so (3 d.p.).
Check: , and
and (3 d.p.).
Example 2: As the sine or cosine of an acute angle
Write each as the sine or cosine of an acute angle: (a) , (b) , (c) .
Solution
Take each angle from to find its acute angle. The sine keeps its sign; the cosine changes sign.
(a) so .
(b) so On the calculator: and .
(c) so
(a) (b) (c)
Example 3: Without a calculator
Given that and , correct to 3 decimal places, write down the values of and .
Solution
and (3 d.p.).
The Sign of the Cosine
For every angle between and , the point is above the line, so the sine is positive whether the angle is acute or obtuse. The sine cannot tell them apart. The cosine can: is to the right of for an acute angle, straight above at , and to the left of for an obtuse angle. In the table, means positive and negative.
| is | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| acute | right of | ||
| above | |||
| obtuse | left of |
What the cosine tells you
For an angle between and :
if , is acute;
if , ;
if , is obtuse.
This is how the cosine rule (lesson 6.6) shows that an angle of a triangle is obtuse.
Example 4: Acute, right or obtuse?
The angles , and are each between and , with , and . (a) Say whether each angle is acute, a right angle or obtuse. (b) Find and , correct to 1 decimal place.
Solution
(a) is positive, so is acute. is negative, so is obtuse. , so .
(b)
The calculator gives the obtuse angle directly: there is nothing to take from .
Check : and so as given.
(a) acute, obtuse, a right angle. (b) , .
Finding an Angle from Its Sine or Cosine
In Secondary 2 an angle came straight from or , because it had to be acute. Now an angle may be anywhere between and , and the sine and the cosine behave differently.
The sine. Below the top of the semicircle, two of its points are at any one height: one at an acute angle and one at minus it. So has two answers: and The calculator gives only the first; the second is yours to find.
At the very top there is only one point, so has the one answer .
The cosine. Only one point of the semicircle is at any one distance across from , to the right or to the left. So has exactly one answer, and gives it: acute when is positive, obtuse when is negative.
An angle between 0° and 180° from its sine or cosine
, where : two answers, (acute) and (obtuse).
: one answer, .
, where : one answer, ; acute if , if , obtuse if .
Example 5: Two answers from a sine
Solve for , giving the angles correct to 1 decimal place.
Solution
The acute answer:
The obtuse answer:
Check on the calculator: which is to 2 decimal places (the angle was rounded, so the sine is a little off).
or .
Example 6: One answer from a cosine
Solve for , giving the angle correct to 1 decimal place.
Solution
The cosine is negative, so the angle is obtuse, as it should be.
There is no second answer: and , positive, not .
(one answer only).
Example 7: An angle of a triangle from its sine
In , . (a) Find the two possible sizes of , correct to 1 decimal place. (b) Given also that , which one is it?
Solution
(a) so , or
Both can be angles of a triangle: the sine alone cannot decide.
(b) If , then more than : no triangle has those two angles.
So (and then
(a) or . (b) .
Lesson 6.4 meets exactly this when the sine rule gives an angle: two possible angles, and a fact about the triangle to decide between them, or two possible triangles.
Common Mistakes
- Giving one answer to . The calculator gives only the acute angle . Between and there is also : give both, or the fact that rules one out.
- Writing . The cosine of an obtuse angle is negative:
- Writing Only the cosine changes sign. The sine of an obtuse angle is positive: .
- Giving minus the answer to as a second answer. is the only one; minus it has the opposite cosine.
- Deciding from the sine whether an angle is obtuse. Every angle between and has a positive sine; only the cosine shows it.
Practice Questions
Give values correct to 3 decimal places and angles correct to 1 decimal place. Every angle is between and . Try each question before opening its solution.
Question 1
Use a calculator to find and . Check each with the acute angle .
ShowHide solution
and
, the same; , and
,
Question 2
Write each as the sine or cosine of an acute angle: (a) (b) (c) (d)
ShowHide solution
(a) .
(b) .
(c)
(d) .
(a) (b) (c) (d)
Question 3
In the figure, is a straight line and . Given that and , correct to 3 decimal places, find and without a calculator.
ShowHide solution
Angles on a straight line: which is obtuse.
,
Question 4
Say whether each angle is acute, a right angle or obtuse, or that you cannot tell: (a) (b) (c) (d)
ShowHide solution
(a) The cosine is negative: is obtuse.
(b) The cosine is positive: is acute.
(c) The cosine is : .
(d) Cannot tell: every angle between and has a positive sine. or
(a) obtuse (b) acute (c) right angle (d) cannot tell ( or )
Question 5
Solve .
ShowHide solution
A cosine gives one angle; it is negative, so the angle is obtuse.
Question 6
Solve .
ShowHide solution
so .
The obtuse answer:
or
Question 7
Solve (a) (b) (c) .
ShowHide solution
(a) Only the top of the semicircle is at height : , one answer.
(b) Only the point straight above is across: .
(c) one answer.
(a) (b) (c)
Question 8
Solve .
ShowHide solution
or
or
Question 9
Solve .
ShowHide solution
, so .
one answer, obtuse.
Question 10
In , . Find the possible sizes of when (a) , (b) .
ShowHide solution
so or
(a) less than , so both are possible.
(b) more than , so cannot be obtuse.
(a) or (b)
Question 11
Ali writes , "because is obtuse". Explain his mistake and give the right value.
ShowHide solution
For an obtuse angle the cosine is negative, not the sine: the point at on the semicircle is still above the line.
(positive)
Question 12
Mei solves and gets . Her friend says there is a second answer, Who is right?
ShowHide solution
so Mei's answer is right.
which is positive, so does not solve . A cosine gives only one angle between and ; it is the sine that gives two.
Mei is right: is the only answer.
Key Points
- An obtuse angle is between and .
- On a semicircle of radius , is the height of the point at the angle , and is its distance across from the centre, negative to the left.
- and
- Between and the sine is always positive. The cosine is positive for an acute angle, at and negative for an obtuse angle.
- (with ) has two answers, and . has one, .
- Take values from the calculator, and use the rules to check them.