Solving Equations with Graphs
How to solve an equation from the graph of a cubic, reciprocal, exponential or power-sum curve: rearrange it so that one side is the curve, draw the suitable straight line, and read where they meet.
Before you start
- In lesson 1.4 you solved with the graph of . Rewritten as , it is solved where the line meets the curve: and .
- Here the same method is used with the curves of 5.1 to 5.4, which the algebra of this course often cannot solve at all.
Where a Curve and a Line Meet
A point lies on the curve when its coordinates make that equation true, and on a line when its is . A point on both has : its -coordinate solves the equation.
The -axis is the line , so the curve's -intercepts solve . A horizontal line gives the solutions of curve , and a sloping line the solutions of curve .
Solving an equation with a graph
The solutions of curve line are the -coordinates of the points where the curve and the line meet, inside the range of drawn. Write only the -coordinates.
Read each to 1 decimal place, with , and check it by substituting into both sides of the equation: they should be nearly equal.
Rearranging to Find the Line
An equation is seldom written as "curve line". Rearrange it so that one side is exactly the expression of the curve you have drawn. What is left on the other side is the straight line to draw: or .
Draw the line from two or three points across the range, and read where it meets the curve.
Example 1: The cubic of 5.1
The graph of for is drawn below, on a scale of 2 cm to 1 unit on both axes. Use it to solve
(a)
(b) .
(c) By drawing a suitable straight line on your graph, solve the equation .
Solution
Here each square is unit across and unit up; on graph paper, use the scale the question gives.
(a) Add to both sides: so . Draw through and .
Check: gives or , .
(b) Make the left side the curve: add to both sides, . Draw through and .
Check in : at , exactly; at , at , Both close to .
The line and the curve cross at a shallow angle near and , so those two readings are the least sure: between these two points the curve is less than above the line, so draw the line carefully.
(c) Divide every term by : . To make the left side , add to both sides: Draw through and .
Check in : at it is ; at , exactly; at , . Each is close to .
(a) (accept to ), ( to ), ( to )
(b) ( to ), ( to ), ( to )
(c) ( to ), ( to ), ( to )
A curve with in it
To make one side , you may need to divide the equation by . That is allowed only for , so first check that is not a solution, and say so.
Example 2: The reciprocal graph of 5.2
The graph of for is drawn on a scale of 1 cm to 1 unit on both axes. Use it to solve
(a)
(b)
(c) .
Solution
(a) The left side is already the curve. Draw through and .
Check: and . Both exact.
(b) is not a solution, since . So divide every term by : , so . Draw through and .
Check: at , and ; at , and The formula gives , that is and .
(c) is not a solution (). Divide by : , so . Draw through and .
The line passes between the two branches of the curve and meets neither. Check: which is never .
(a) and (b) (accept to ) and ( to ) (c) No solution.
Equations Algebra Cannot Solve
Equations such as and cannot be solved by any algebra in this course. The graph is the method.
Example 3: The exponential graph of 5.3
The graph of for (5.3) is drawn on a scale of 2 cm to 1 unit on both axes. Use it to solve
(a)
(b)
(c) .
Solution
Here each square is unit on both axes; on graph paper, use the scale the question gives.
(a) Draw the line . (b) Rearrange: ; draw through and . (c) Rearrange: ; draw through and .
Checks: (a) , close to . (b) exactly, so ; and . (c) and .
(a) (accept to ) (b) ( to ) and ( to ) (c) ( to )
How Many Solutions?
Counting solutions
The number of solutions is the number of points where the curve and the line meet inside the range drawn.
A line that just touches the curve meets it once there: one solution, not two. A line that misses the curve gives no solution.
To count solutions a sketch is usually enough; where the line passes close to a turning point, use an accurate graph. To find their values, you always need an accurate graph.
Example 4: Counting from a graph and from a sketch
(a) Use the graph of from 5.4, drawn using a scale of 1 cm to represent 1 unit on both axes, to say how many solutions each equation has: and .
(b) Use a sketch to find how many solutions has.
Solution
(a) Draw and on the graph of 5.4.
The line lies where the graph has no point (5.4: no point has between and ): has no solution.
The line touches the right-hand branch at its turning point : one solution, . Check: . A touch is hard to place exactly, so a reading from to is fair.
(b) Rearrange: . Sketch and the line .
They meet once, a little to the right of . The sketch gives the number of solutions, not their value.
(a) : none; : one, (b) One solution, a little more than .
From a Line to Its Equation
Examinations also ask the other way round: a line is drawn on the graph, and you find the equation its meeting points solve. Put curve line, and rearrange to the form the question gives.
Example 5: Finding the equation
The line is drawn on the graph of for , drawn using a scale of 1 cm to represent 1 unit on both axes.
(a) The -coordinates of the points where the line meets the curve are the solutions of . Find the value of and of .
(b) Write down these solutions.
Solution
(a) At a meeting point, . Multiply every term by (): . Collect the terms on one side: . So , with and .
(b) Read the -coordinates of the two meeting points. Check with the formula: , that is and .
(a) , (b) (accept to ) and ( to )
Common Mistakes
- Writing the -coordinates of the meeting points. The solutions are the -coordinates.
- Rearranging so that neither side is the curve drawn. One side must be exactly the curve's expression.
- Dividing by without saying that : check first that is not a solution.
- Counting meeting points outside the range drawn. The graph shows only the solutions inside it.
- Counting a touch as two solutions. A line that touches the curve meets it once.
- Giving more than 1 decimal place from a graph. A graph is good to about 1 decimal place.
Practice Questions
Use the graphs of the examples (or draw them on graph paper to the scales given). A reading is fair within the range given after "accept". The questions get harder as you go.
Question 1
Give the straight line you would draw to solve each equation with the graph named.
With : (a) (b) (c) (d) .
With : (e) .
With : (f) .
ShowHide solution
(a) Add : . (b) Add : . (c) Add : so .
(d) Halve every term first: ; then add :
(e) is not a solution (). Divide by : , so .
(f) Add : .
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f)
Question 2
Use the graph of (Example 1) to solve .
ShowHide solution
From Question 1(d), draw the line through and .
Check both sides: at , and ; at , and ; each pair nearly equal. At , and : exact, at the end of the range drawn.
(accept to ), ( to ), ( to )
Question 3
Use the graph of (Example 2) to solve (a) (b) .
ShowHide solution
Draw through and , and through and .
(a) Check: and both exact.
(b) Check: and : both exact. The line crosses the curve at a shallow angle here, so the readings are less sure.
(a) (accept to ), ( to ) (b) ( to ), ( to )
Question 4
Use the graph of (Example 3) to solve (a) (b) .
ShowHide solution
(a) Draw . (b) Halve both sides first: ; draw through and .
(a) Check: , exact. (b) Check both sides: at , and at , and each pair nearly equal.
(a) (accept to ) (b) ( to ) and ( to )
Question 5
Use the graph of (Example 5) to solve .
ShowHide solution
The line meets only the right-hand branch. Check: and each close to . On the right the curve rises slowly, so that reading is the less sure.
(accept to ) and ( to )
Question 6
The line is drawn on the graph of for .
(a) The -coordinates of the points where it meets the curve are the solutions of . Find the value of and of .
(b) Write down the solutions.
ShowHide solution
(a) . Subtract from both sides: . So and .
(b) The line meets the curve twice inside the range drawn. Check in : at , close to ; at , exactly. (The equation has a third solution, below , outside the range drawn.)
(a) , (b) (accept to ) and ( to )
Question 7
From each sketch, say how many solutions the equation has.
(P) (Q) (R)
ShowHide solution
(P) The curve is in the second and fourth quadrants; the line is in the first and third. They never meet: no solution.
(Q) The line crosses the first-quadrant branch twice, and misses the third-quadrant branch: two solutions.
(R) The line stays below the ∪: no solution.
(P) none (Q) two (R) none
Question 8
The graph of is drawn for only. For which values of does have exactly two solutions in this range? (Hint: slide a horizontal line up and down, and count where it meets the curve drawn; look at both ends of the range.)
ShowHide solution
The curve drawn ends at and , and turns at and .
From to the curve falls from to . A line with , such as , crosses this piece once and the rising piece once: two solutions. At it meets the rising piece once and the end : still two. At it only touches the turning point : one. Between and the line crosses only the rising piece: one solution.
The left end is the same, upside down: two solutions for .
Without the range (on the whole curve) every between and would give three solutions: here the ends of the range decide the answer.
Exactly two solutions when or .
Question 9
Explain why has no solution.
ShowHide solution
Draw on the graph of : the line runs through the second and fourth quadrants, the curve through the first and third. They never meet.
In words: for , is positive and negative; for it is the other way round. A positive number is never equal to a negative one.
The curve lies in the first and third quadrants and the line in the second and fourth, so they never meet.
Question 10
The graph of for (5.1) is drawn using a scale of 2 cm to 1 unit across and 2 cm to 5 units up.
(a) (i) On the same axes, draw the line . (ii) Write down the -coordinates of the points where the line meets the curve. (iii) These values of are solutions of the equation . Find the value of and of .
(b) By drawing a suitable straight line on your graph, solve the equation .
ShowHide solution
(a)(ii) The line meets the curve three times.
Check: at , at , at , each close to .
(iii) , so : , .
(b) Make one side the curve: gives ; add to both sides: . Draw through and .
Check: gives or .
(a)(ii) (accept to ), ( to ), ( to ) (iii) ,
(b) , , (each accept )
Question 11
Find the fault in each answer.
(a) To solve , Wei Ming drew and wrote "the solution is ".
(b) To solve with the graph of , Siti drew the line .
(c) With drawn for , Raj solved for and wrote .
ShowHide solution
(a) is the -coordinate of the meeting point. The solution is its -coordinate, (check: ).
(b) Adding to both sides gives : the line is , not .
(c) The line meets the curve only beyond , outside the range asked for (at , as he found by drawing the curve past its range). Inside the curve never reaches : its highest value there is .
(a) He gave the -coordinate; (accept to ) (b) The line should be (c) There is no solution for : the line meets the curve only beyond .
Key Points
- The solutions of curve line are the -coordinates of the points where they meet, inside the range drawn.
- Rearrange the equation so that one side is exactly the curve drawn; the other side is the line to draw.
- Before dividing by , check that is not a solution.
- Read solutions to 1 decimal place with , and check by substituting into both sides.
- The number of meeting points is the number of solutions; a touch counts once; a sketch is usually enough to count, but not where the line passes close to a turning point.
- A drawn line gives the equation it solves: put curve line and rearrange.
- The graph solves equations such as that algebra in this course cannot.