Estimating the Gradient of a Curve
How to draw a tangent to a curve by eye, estimate its gradient from a large step in the units of the scales, and use it as the rate of change at an instant, such as a speed.
Before you start
- In Secondary 1 you found the gradient of a straight line from a step: vertical change ÷ horizontal change, in the units of the axes. For and it is .
- On a graph of a setting the gradient is a rate: on a distance-time graph of a coach it is the speed, such as km/h.
The Gradient of a Curve
A straight line is equally steep all along, so it has one gradient. A curve is not: falls on the left, is flat at its turning point and rises more and more steeply on the right. So we speak of the gradient of a curve at a point.
At each point there is one straight line that runs the same way as the curve there, just touching it: the tangent at that point. Its gradient is the gradient of the curve at that point.
The gradient of a curve
The gradient of a curve at a point is the gradient of the tangent to the curve at that point.
The tangent at falls, so the curve falls there and its gradient is negative. The tangent at rises steeply: the curve is steeper there. These are the true gradients; when you draw a tangent by eye you find them approximately, as the rest of this lesson shows.
Drawing a Tangent and Finding Its Gradient
Estimating the gradient of a curve at a point
1. Draw the tangent by eye. Place a ruler at the point so that it just touches the curve there: near the point the curve lies on one side of the ruler, bending away from it on both sides. Draw the line long, across most of the grid. (Away from the point, a tangent may meet the curve again. At a point where the curve changes its bend, such as on , the tangent does cross the curve; this course does not ask for tangents there.)
2. Choose two points on the tangent far apart, where it is easy to read, on grid lines where possible.
3. Draw the step between them and find vertical change ÷ horizontal change, reading both changes in the units of the scales, not in squares.
4. Write the answer with . If the division comes out exactly, give it as it is (); if not, give it to 3 significant figures ().
Example 1: A positive gradient
The graph of is drawn for . By drawing a tangent, find the gradient of the curve at the point .
Solution
Place the ruler at so that it touches the curve there and the curve bends away from it on both sides, and draw the tangent. Here each square is 1 unit on both axes.
The tangent passes through about and , both on grid lines and far apart.
Horizontal change . Vertical change .
Gradient .
The gradient of the curve at is about (accept to ).
Why a large step, and why it is an estimate
The tangent is drawn by eye and its points are read from a scale, so each reading may be a little out. Over a large step those small errors are a small part of the changes; over a tiny step they can be most of them.
Two careful pupils will draw slightly different tangents and get slightly different gradients, such as and for Example 1. Both are right if they are close to the true gradient: that is why the answer carries a range.
Example 2: A negative gradient
The graph of is drawn for , with 1 unit to a square on both axes. Estimate the gradient of the curve at the point .
Solution
Draw the tangent at . It runs down from left to right, as the curve does there.
The tangent meets the axes at about and : two points far apart on grid lines.
Going from left to right: horizontal change ; vertical change (the step goes down).
Gradient .
The gradient at is about (accept to ). The curve falls there, so the gradient is negative.
Gradient 0 at a Turning Point
At a turning point the curve stops rising and starts falling, or the other way round. There the tangent is horizontal, so the gradient of the curve is . Where the curve rises from left to right its gradient is positive; where it falls, negative.
Example 3: Turning points
The graph of (from 5.1) has turning points and . Find the gradient of the curve at each, and say where on the curve, for , the gradient is positive and where it is negative.
Solution
Place the ruler at each turning point: the line that just touches the curve there is horizontal.
A horizontal line has vertical change for any step, so its gradient is . A tangent drawn by eye might give or ; anything from to is fair.
Between and the curve rises: the gradient is positive. Between and it falls: negative. Between and it rises again: positive.
The gradient is at both turning points. It is positive between and and between and , and negative between and .
Rate of Change at an Instant
On a graph of a setting, the gradient of a curve at a point is the rate of change at that instant, in the units of the vertical axis per unit of the horizontal axis. On a distance-time graph it is the speed at that instant.
This is not the same as the average speed, which is total distance ÷ total time: the gradient of the straight line (a chord) from the start to that point.
Example 4: Speed at an instant
A train leaves a station. Its distance metres from the station seconds later is for . Some values are given in the table.
(a) Using a scale of 1 cm to 2 s across and 1 cm to 20 m up, draw the distance-time graph and, by drawing a tangent, estimate the speed of the train when .
(b) Find its average speed over the first 10 seconds, and compare.
Solution
(a) Plot the points and join them with a smooth curve. Each square is 2 s across and 20 m up. Draw the tangent at .
The tangent passes through about and , both on grid lines and far apart.
Speed m/s.
(b) In the first 10 s the train goes m. Average speed m/s: the gradient of the dashed chord from to .
The speed at is twice the average so far: the curve gets steeper, so the train is speeding up.
(a) About m/s (accept to ). (b) m/s; at the train is going faster than its average so far, because it is speeding up.
Common Mistakes
- Drawing a line that cuts across the curve at the point instead of just touching it. Check that the curve bends away from the ruler on both sides.
- Using a small step. Choose two points far apart on the tangent.
- Counting squares when the two scales differ. Read the changes from the numbers on the axes.
- Getting the sign wrong. Where the curve falls from left to right, the gradient is negative.
- Writing the gradient as exact, or cutting it to one figure. Write it with , to 3 significant figures unless it comes out exact.
- Using the chord from the start to the point (the average rate) instead of the tangent at the point (the rate at that instant).
Practice Questions
Draw each tangent with a ruler on the graph given (or on your own copy of it). A gradient is fair within the range given after "accept". The questions get harder as you go.
Question 1
The graph of is drawn below, with 1 unit to a square on both axes. By drawing a tangent, find the gradient of the curve at the point .
ShowHide solution
The tangent passes through about and , both on grid lines and far apart. Gradient
About (accept to ).
Question 2
The graph of is drawn below for ; each square is unit across and unit up. Estimate the gradient of the curve at the point , where .
ShowHide solution
At , Draw the tangent there. It passes through about and .
Gradient The scales differ: the step is squares across but unit, so counting squares would give , half the gradient.
About (accept to ).
Question 3
The graph of is drawn for on a scale of 2 cm to 1 unit across and 2 cm to 5 units up. Each square is 0.5 unit across and 2.5 units up. Find the gradient of the curve (a) at the point where , (b) at the point where .
ShowHide solution
The scales differ, so read every change from the numbers on the axes, not by counting squares.
(a) The tangent at leaves the grid above near , so the clear points on it are and : horizontal change , vertical change . Gradient .
(b) The tangent at passes through about and , both on grid lines: horizontal change , vertical change Gradient .
Counting squares in (b) would give squares up for squares across, : far too small, because one square up is units and one square across is unit.
(a) About (accept to ) (b) about (accept to ).
Question 4
The graph of (from 5.3) is drawn for , with each square 1 unit on both axes. Estimate the gradient of the curve (a) at , (b) at .
ShowHide solution
(a) The tangent at passes through about and . Gradient
(b) The tangent at passes through about and . Gradient
The curve is steeper at : the gradient of grows as grows. (The true gradients are and , to 3 significant figures.)
(a) About (accept to ) (b) about (accept to ).
Question 5
The graph of for is the graph of Question 3.
(a) At which values of is the gradient of the curve ?
(b) Where on the curve is the gradient positive, and where negative?
ShowHide solution
(a) The gradient is where the tangent is horizontal: at the turning points and .
(b) Between and the curve falls; between and it rises; between and it falls.
(a) and (b) Positive between and ; negative between and and between and .
Question 6
On the graph of for (Example 2), is the curve steeper at or at ? Draw tangents to decide, and estimate both gradients.
ShowHide solution
At the tangent passes through about and : it falls for across, so the gradient
At the tangent passes through about and : it falls for across, so the gradient
The steeper point has the gradient larger in size: about against about .
Steeper at : gradient about (accept to ), against about at (accept to ).
Question 7
For the gradient of at , Aisha got , Daniel got and Mei got from tangents they drew. The true gradient is . Which answers are fair, and what might Mei have done?
ShowHide solution
Each drew the tangent by eye and read two points on it from a scale, so each answer is an estimate. Answers within about a tenth of the true gradient, from to , are fair: Aisha's and Daniel's.
Mei's line is too steep. A line through steeper than the tangent cuts across the curve there instead of just touching it: the curve does not bend away from it on both sides.
Aisha's and Daniel's are fair (within to ). Mei's is too steep: her line probably cut across the curve at instead of just touching it.
Question 8
The number of bacteria in a dish, thousand, hours after the start is . Its graph is drawn for . By drawing a tangent, estimate the rate at which the number is growing when .
ShowHide solution
The tangent passes through about and . Gradient
The units are those of the axes: thousand bacteria per hour.
About thousand bacteria per hour (accept to ).
Question 9
A car brakes. Its distance metres from the point where it starts braking, seconds later, is for , given in the table.
(a) Using a scale of 1 cm to 1 s across and 1 cm to 10 m up, draw the graph and estimate its speed when .
(b) Find its average speed over the first 4 seconds.
(c) Explain why the two answers differ.
ShowHide solution
(a) Each square is 1 s across and 10 m up.
The tangent at passes through about and , both on grid lines. Speed m/s.
(b) Average speed m/s, the gradient of the dashed chord.
(c) The curve gets less steep: the car is slowing down. It went faster than m/s earlier in the 4 seconds, so its average is higher than its speed at .
(a) About m/s (accept to ) (b) m/s (c) The car is slowing down, so its speed at is less than its average speed so far.
Question 10
Three pupils estimated the gradient of at . Find each one's fault.
(a) Ali drew the line through and and got .
(b) Ben's grid had 1 unit across and 2 units up to a square. His tangent went 2 squares across and 4 squares up, so he wrote .
(c) Chen used a step from to and read the rise as , getting .
ShowHide solution
(a) The line through and cuts across the curve: it is a chord, not a tangent. Its gradient, , is the average over .
(b) He counted squares. 4 squares up is units and 2 squares across is units: gradient .
(c) The step is far too small: a reading error of in the rise changes the answer by . A step 2 units across gives a much better estimate.
(a) A chord, not a tangent (b) Counted squares on unequal scales; the gradient is about (c) A tiny step, so small reading errors swamp the answer.
Key Points
- The gradient of a curve at a point is the gradient of the tangent to the curve at that point.
- Draw the tangent with a ruler so that it just touches the curve at the point, the curve bending away from it on both sides.
- Find its gradient from two points far apart: vertical change ÷ horizontal change, in the units of the scales, not squares.
- The answer is an estimate: write it with , to 3 significant figures unless exact.
- At a turning point the tangent is horizontal and the gradient is ; where the curve rises it is positive, where it falls negative.
- On a graph of a setting the gradient is the rate of change at that instant: on a distance-time graph, the speed then. The chord from the start gives the average.