Other Graphs of Real-World Situations
Conversion graphs that do not pass through the origin, step graphs for charges "or part of it", the depth of water filling containers of different shapes, timetables and tables, and sketching a graph from a description.
Before you start
- In Secondary 1, S$1 = RM3.50 gave the conversion line through the origin: S$30 is RM105.
- A taxi's fare of S$4 plus S$0.60 a km gave a line starting at S$4 on the cost axis: a fixed charge.
- In Secondary 2, two bicycle shops' cost lines crossed at hours and S$18: below hours shop A was cheaper, above it shop B.
- Every amount in Singapore dollars on this page is written S$, since other currencies appear too.
A Conversion Graph Not Through the Origin
A currency conversion line at one rate, with no fee, passes through the origin: S$0 is RM0, and twice the dollars buys twice the ringgit. Temperature is different. Water freezes at °C, which is °F, and boils at °C, which is °F. The two scales are joined by the formula from Secondary 1, whose graph is a straight line that does not pass through the origin.
Example 1: Celsius and Fahrenheit
The graph of is drawn for .
(a) Use it to change °C to °F.
(b) Use it to change °F to °C.
(c) At what temperature do the two scales give the same number?
(d) is twice . Is the °F reading for °C twice the °F reading for °C?
Solution
(a) Go up from on the °C axis to the line, then across.
The reading is a little below : about °F. Check:
(b) Go across from on the °F axis to the line, then down: °C. Check: .
(c) The line passes through : So °C is °F.
(d) °C is °F and °C is °F: is not twice . Because the line does not pass through the origin, doubling one number does not double the other.
(a) About °F (b) °C (c) At (d) No: °F is not twice °F.
Step Graphs
Some charges go up in jumps: "S$0.80 for each half hour or part of it". A stay of h min costs the same as h min, and h min costs one step more. The graph is a row of flat pieces, a step graph. Notices often say "or part thereof", which means the same.
Reading a step graph
Each flat piece is one charge. At a jump, the filled dot marks the end the piece includes and the open circle the end it does not.
For "up to 1 hour" or "or part of it", each piece includes its right end: exactly hours is read at the filled dot on the lower piece.
Example 2: A car park
A shopping centre's car park (an invented example) charges S$1.20 for the first hour or part of it, and S$0.80 for each further half hour or part of it. The graph shows stays of up to hours.
(a) Find the charge for h min.
(b) Find the charge for exactly hours.
(c) What is the longest stay for S$4.40?
Solution
(a) After the first hour, h min is left: two whole half hours and minutes, which is part of a third. So half hours are charged.
Charge S$3.60.
(b) Exactly hours is hour and half hours: S$2.80. On the graph it is the filled dot at the right end of the piece from to hours; the open circle above it, on the next piece, is not included.
(c) S$4.40 is the piece from to hours, with its filled dot at hours. A stay even a minute over hours costs S$5.20. The longest stay for S$4.40 is hours.
(a) S$3.60 (b) S$2.80 (c) hours.
Filling Containers
Water runs into a container at a constant rate: the same volume every second. The graph of the depth of the water against time depends on the container's shape.
The depth of water against time, at a constant rate of flow
Where the container is the same width all the way up (a cylinder or a prism), the depth rises by the same amount each second: a straight line.
The narrower the container, the faster the depth rises: a steeper line.
Where the container gets wider as it fills, the depth rises more and more slowly: a curve getting less steep. Where it gets narrower, a curve getting steeper.
A container made of two parts gives a graph in two pieces, one for each part.
Example 3: Four containers
Water flows at the same constant rate into each container: A, a cylinder; B, a cylinder of the same height and half the radius; C, a cone on its point, as wide and as tall as A; D, a cylinder as wide as A with one as narrow as B on top, each half as tall as A. Each container starts empty (the pictures show them part filled). Sketch the graph of the depth of water against time for each.
Solution
A: the cylinder is the same width all the way up, so the depth rises steadily: a straight line.
B: the same volume each second makes a deeper layer in a narrower cylinder (half the radius, so a quarter of the area: four times as deep), so its line is steeper.
C: the cone is narrow at the bottom and widens as it fills, so the depth rises quickly at first and then more and more slowly: a curve getting less steep.
D: the wide part fills first, a gentle straight line; then the narrow part, a steeper straight line.
The sketches share their scales: B fills in a quarter of A's time, C in a third (a cone holds a third of the cylinder round it), and D's narrow part rises four times as fast as its wide part.
A a straight line; B a steeper straight line; C a curve getting less steep; D two straight pieces, the second steeper.
Tables and Timetables
A timetable gives times in the 24-hour form. A journey time is found in hours and minutes, not by subtracting the times as numbers: from 0830 to 0945 is h min, not minutes or hours.
Example 4: An island ferry
One ferry runs between a mainland jetty and an island km away (an invented timetable).
(a) How long does each crossing take?
(b) Mr Lim must reach the island by 1300. Which is the latest ferry he can take?
(c) Aisyah reaches the mainland jetty at 1015. How long must she wait for a ferry?
(d) Find the ferry's average speed while crossing.
(e) Draw the ferry's distance-time graph from 0800 to 1000, with the distance from the mainland jetty.
Mainland to island (times invented):
| Leaves mainland | Arrives at island |
|---|---|
| 0800 | 0840 |
| 1000 | 1040 |
| 1200 | 1240 |
| 1400 | 1440 |
Island to mainland:
| Leaves island | Arrives at mainland |
|---|---|
| 0900 | 0940 |
| 1100 | 1140 |
| 1300 | 1340 |
| 1500 | 1540 |
Solution
(a) 0800 to 0840 is minutes; every crossing in the table takes minutes.
(b) The 1200 ferry arrives at 1240, before 1300. The next leaves at 1400, too late. He must take the 1200.
(c) The next ferry from the mainland after 1015 leaves at 1200. From 1015 to 1100 is min, and 1100 to 1200 is h: she waits h min.
(d) km in min h: average speed km/h.
(e) Join (0800, ), (0840, ), (0900, ), (0940, ) and (1000, ). The flat pieces are the waits at each end.
(a) minutes (b) The 1200 ferry (c) h min (d) km/h.
Sketching a Graph from a Description
A sketch shows the shape of a graph, with no scale. Take the description stage by stage. For each, ask: does the quantity rise, fall or stay the same? Steadily (a straight piece) or faster and faster, or slower and slower (a curve)? Faster than in another stage (steeper)?
Example 5: A bath
An empty bath with upright sides (the same width all the way up) is filled from a tap at a constant rate. The tap is turned off and the water is left for a while. Then the plug is pulled, and the bath empties at a constant rate, faster than it filled. Sketch the graph of the depth of water against time.
Solution
Filling at a constant rate: the depth rises steadily, a straight piece going up.
Left standing: the depth stays the same, a flat piece.
Emptying at a constant rate, faster than it filled: a straight piece going down, steeper than the first.
A straight line up from the origin, a flat piece, then a steeper straight line down to the time axis.
Common Mistakes
- Reading a step graph at the open circle. At a jump, the charge is the one at the filled dot.
- Forgetting a fixed charge: the line starts up the cost axis, not at the origin.
- Thinking a conversion line that does not pass through the origin doubles one value when the other doubles: the °F reading for °C is not twice the one for °C.
- Drawing a container's curve the wrong way: the depth rises faster where the container is narrower, so the graph is steeper there.
- Subtracting 24-hour times as numbers: 0945 − 0830 is h min, not .
Practice Questions
Read values from the graphs given, then check them by working where you can. The questions get harder as you go.
Question 1
One day a bank sells Australian dollars at S$1 = A$1.18 (an invented rate).
(a) Draw a conversion graph for S$0 to S$100.
(b) Use it to find how many Australian dollars S$40 buys.
(c) Use it to find how much A$100 costs in Singapore dollars.
ShowHide solution
(a) S$0 buys A$0 and S$100 buys A$118: join and .
(b) Up from S$40 and across: about A$47. Check: . A bank, like a money changer, hands over whole units, rounded down: A$47.
(c) Across from A$100 and down: about S$85. Check: S$84.75 to the nearest cent.
(b) About A$47 (A$47.20 at this rate; the bank hands over A$47) (c) About S$85 (S$84.75 to the nearest cent).
Question 2
Use the temperature graph of Example 1.
(a) Change °C to °F.
(b) Change °F to °C.
(c) A recipe from an American website says to cool a cake to below °F. Is °C cool enough?
ShowHide solution
(a) Up from °C: about °F. Check:
(b) Across from °F: °C. Check:
(c) °C is °F (Example 1), below °F: yes.
(a) °F (b) °C (c) Yes: °C is °F.
Question 3
Two plumbers' charges (invented): P charges S$50 to come and S$40 an hour; Q charges S$70 to come and S$30 an hour. Their graphs are drawn below.
(a) Read the time for which they charge the same, and the charge.
(b) Check by working.
(c) Which plumber is cheaper for a job of hour, and for one of hours?
ShowHide solution
(a) The lines cross at X: hours, S$130.
(b) gives , ; the charge is .
(c) For hour: P S$90, Q S$100, so P is cheaper. For hours: P S$170, Q S$160, so Q is cheaper. P is cheaper for jobs under hours, Q for jobs over hours.
(a) hours, S$130 (c) P for hour (S$90 against S$100); Q for hours (S$160 against S$170).
Question 4
Use the car park's step graph of Example 2. Find the charge for (a) minutes, (b) exactly h min, (c) h min.
ShowHide solution
(a) minutes is part of the first hour: S$1.20.
(b) The first hour and one half hour: S$2.00, the filled dot at hours.
(c) After the first hour, h min is left: five whole half hours and minutes, which is part of a sixth. S$6.00.
(a) S$1.20 (b) S$2.00 (c) S$6.00.
Question 5
A taxi company's fare (invented) is S$3.90 for the first km or less, then S$0.25 for each further m or part of it.
(a) Draw the step graph of the fare for trips of up to km.
(b) Find the fare for a trip of km.
(c) Find the fare for a trip of exactly km.
ShowHide solution
(a) The fare jumps by S$0.25 just after km, km, km, km and km, each piece including its right end: S$3.90 up to km, S$4.15 up to km, S$4.40 up to km, S$4.65 up to km, S$4.90 up to km and S$5.15 up to km.
(b) After the first km, km m is left: , so parts of m are charged. Fare S$4.90.
(c) After the first km, m is left: exactly parts. Fare S$4.40, the filled dot at km.
(b) S$4.90 (c) S$4.40.
Question 6
A courier's price list (invented): S$0.90 for a letter of up to g, and S$0.30 more for each further g or part of it, up to g.
(a) Draw the step graph of the price against mass.
(b) Find the price of a g letter and of a g letter.
(c) What is the heaviest letter that can be sent for S$1.80?
ShowHide solution
(a) Prices: up to g S$0.90; over g up to g S$1.20; up to g S$1.50; up to g S$1.80; up to g S$2.10.
(b) g is over g and up to g: S$1.50. g is exactly at a jump; "up to g" includes it: S$1.50.
(c) The piece at S$1.80 runs from just over g up to g, its filled dot at g: the heaviest is g.
(b) S$1.50 and S$1.50 (c) g.
Question 7
Water flows at a constant rate into each container: P, a bowl (a hemisphere, flat face up); Q, a container wider at the bottom than at the top; R, a cylinder. Match each to its sketch of depth against time.
ShowHide solution
P, the bowl, widens as it fills: the depth rises more and more slowly, sketch 3.
Q narrows as it fills: the depth rises more and more quickly, sketch 1.
R, the cylinder, is the same width all the way up: a straight line, sketch 2.
P 3, Q 1, R 2.
Question 8
A container is a cone on its point with a cylinder of the same radius on top. Water flows in at a constant rate until it is full. Sketch the graph of the depth against time.
ShowHide solution
The cone part widens as it fills: a curve getting less steep.
The cylinder is the same width all the way up: a straight line. It is as wide as the top of the cone, so the line goes on at the gradient the curve ends with.
A curve getting less steep while the cone fills, then a straight line while the cylinder fills.
Question 9
Use the ferry timetable of Example 4. A bus from the town to the mainland jetty leaves at 1030, 1100 and 1130 and takes minutes. Mrs Tan wants to be at the jetty at least minutes before the 1200 ferry. Which is the latest bus she can take?
ShowHide solution
She must be at the jetty by 1150.
The 1100 bus arrives min later, at 1135: in time. The 1130 bus arrives at 1205: too late.
The 1100 bus (it arrives at 1135).
Question 10
The table shows the charge of a phone battery, as a percentage, while it charges. It charges at one steady rate up to %, then at a slower steady rate.
(a) Draw the graph from the table.
(b) Read the charge after minutes.
(c) Find the rate of charging, in % per minute, in each stage.
| Time (min) | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charge (%) |
ShowHide solution
(a) Plot the points and join them: one straight piece to , then a less steep piece to .
(b) Up from minutes and across: %. Check: .
(c) First stage: % in min, % per minute. Second stage: % in min, % per minute.
(b) % (c) % per minute, then % per minute.
Question 11
A phone is fully charged at 0700. It is used lightly until 1200, so the charge falls slowly and steadily; it is used for a video call from 1200 to 1400, so the charge falls quickly and steadily; then it is charged at a steady rate until it is full again. Sketch the graph of the charge against time.
ShowHide solution
Three stages: a gentle straight fall, a steep straight fall, then a rise back to the top.
The middle piece is the steepest fall: the video call uses the battery fastest.
A gentle fall, a steeper fall, then a rise back to full.
Key Points
- A conversion line through the origin doubles one value when the other doubles; one that does not, such as , does not.
- A fixed charge starts the cost line up the cost axis. Where two cost lines cross, the costs are equal; on each side a different one is cheaper.
- A step graph ("or part of it") is read at the filled dot at a jump, never at the open circle.
- Filling at a constant rate: a straight line for a container of the same width all the way up, steeper for a narrower one; a curve getting less steep where it widens, steeper where it narrows.
- Work out times from a timetable in hours and minutes, not by subtracting the 24-hour times as numbers.
- To sketch from a description, take each stage: rising, falling or steady; straight or curving; steeper or gentler than another.