Independent Events
Events where one does not change the probability of the other, the multiplication rule P(A and B) = P(A) × P(B) that holds for them and only for them, drawing with replacement, and how independent events differ from mutually exclusive ones.
What You Should Already Know
- From lesson 2.2: multiply the probabilities along a path of a tree diagram. For a fair coin tossed twice,
- From lesson 2.3: two events are mutually exclusive if they cannot happen at the same time; then , and holds only for such events.
Events That Do Not Affect Each Other
Toss a fair coin and roll a fair die. Whatever the coin shows, the die still shows a 6 with probability : the coin cannot change the die. Now take a sweet from a bag and eat it, then take another: the bag has one sweet fewer, so the first sweet changes the chances for the second.
Independent events
Two events and are independent if whether one happens does not change the probability of the other.
Events from separate objects (two dice, a coin and a die, two spinners) are independent, and so are the results of draws with replacement, where each item is put back before the next is drawn.
| Independent | Not independent |
|---|---|
| Getting a head on the first toss of a coin and a head on the second toss | Taking a red sweet from a bag and eating it, then taking a red sweet (the bag has changed: lesson 2.5) |
| Getting a 6 on the red die and a 6 on the blue die | Getting a 2 and getting a 5 on one roll of a die (if one happens, the other cannot) |
| Drawing a red ball, putting it back, then drawing a red ball again | Getting an even number and getting a 4 on one roll of a die (a 4 makes "even" certain) |
The Multiplication Rule
For independent events, the probability that both happen is the product of their probabilities. Lesson 2.2 multiplied along the paths of a tree in just this way; Example 2 shows on a possibility diagram why the product is right.
Multiplying probabilities for "and"
If and are independent,
This holds only for independent events.
For three or more independent events,
Example 1: A head and a 6
A fair coin is tossed and a fair die is rolled. Find the probability of getting a head and a 6.
Solution
The coin does not affect the die, so getting a head and getting a 6 are independent.
On a tree diagram, this is the product along the path H, 6.
Check on the possibility diagram of a coin and a die (lesson 2.1): H6 is 1 of the 12 equally likely cells.
Example 2: Why the probabilities multiply
A red die and a blue die, both fair, are rolled. Find the probability that the red die shows an even number and the blue die shows a number greater than 4. Check your answer on a possibility diagram.
Solution
The dice are separate, so the events are independent.
and
Check: shade the cells in both events.
The shaded cells form a block of 3 columns (the even numbers of the red die) and 2 rows (the 5 and 6 of the blue die): cells of . So the numbers of cells multiply, and so do the probabilities.
; the 6 shaded cells of 36 agree.
Example 3: Three independent events
Aisha, Bala and Chen take a swimming test. The probabilities that they pass are 0.9, 0.8 and 0.75, and no result affects another. Find the probability that (a) all three pass; (b) Aisha and Bala pass but Chen fails; (c) none of them passes.
Solution
The three events are independent, so multiply. The probabilities of failing are , and .
(a)
(b)
(c)
(a) 0.54; (b) 0.18; (c) 0.005.
Drawing With Replacement
When an item is drawn from a bag, noted and put back before the next draw, the bag is the same at every draw. This is drawing with replacement. The draws are independent, so every draw has the same probabilities, and they multiply.
Example 4: Two balls with replacement
A bag holds 3 red and 2 blue balls. A ball is drawn at random, its colour is noted and it is put back; then a second ball is drawn at random. Find the probability that (a) both balls are red; (b) the two balls are of different colours.
Solution
The first ball is put back, so the second draw is from the same 3 red and 2 blue balls: and at both draws.
(a)
(b) Different colours: red then blue, or blue then red, the amber paths. They cannot both happen, so add:
Check:
(a) ; (b) .
Without replacement
If the first ball is not put back, the bag changes before the second draw, and the draws are not independent. Lesson 2.5 works this: is then , not .
Example 5: Cards with replacement
Five cards are numbered 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. A card is taken at random, its number is noted and it is put back; then a second card is taken at random. (a) Draw a possibility diagram. Find the probability that (b) both numbers are odd; (c) the same card is taken twice.
Solution
(a) The card is put back, so the second card can be any of the 5, the first one included: equally likely cells.
(b) The draws are independent: The 9 shaded cells agree.
(c) The 5 ringed cells, from (1, 1) to (5, 5):
These 5 cells are outcomes only because the card is put back. Without replacement (lesson 2.5) they are crossed out.
(b) ; (c) .
Independent or Mutually Exclusive?
The two words are easy to confuse, but they ask different questions. "Mutually exclusive" asks whether the events can happen together; "independent" asks whether one changes the probability of the other.
| Mutually exclusive | Independent |
|---|---|
| They cannot happen at the same time | One does not change the probability of the other |
| Add to find | Multiply to find |
| A 2 and a 5 on one roll of a die | A head on a coin and a 6 on a die |
Never both
If and are both more than 0, mutually exclusive events are never independent: if happens, cannot, so changes the probability of to 0.
In the same way, independent events whose probabilities are both more than 0 are never mutually exclusive: is then more than 0, so they can happen together.
Example 6: Which kind of events?
For each pair of events, say whether they are mutually exclusive, independent or neither. (a) A fair coin is tossed and a fair die is rolled: a head; a 6. (b) A fair die is rolled once: a 2; a 5. (c) A fair die is rolled once: an even number; a 4.
Solution
(a) The coin does not affect the die: independent. They can happen together, since is not 0 (Example 1), so they are not mutually exclusive.
(b) One roll cannot show a 2 and a 5: mutually exclusive. , not so they are not independent: rolling a 2 makes a 5 impossible.
(c) A 4 is even, so both happen when a 4 is rolled: not mutually exclusive.
Count: the only outcome that is even and a 4 is the 4, so
Multiplying would give which is wrong: a 4 makes "even" certain, so the events are not independent.
(a) Independent; (b) mutually exclusive; (c) neither.
"And" and "or"
"And": multiply only when the events are independent, or along a path of a tree diagram. Otherwise, when the outcomes are equally likely, count the outcomes that are in both events.
"Or": add only when the events are mutually exclusive (lesson 2.3), or for separate paths of a tree diagram.
Common Mistakes
- Multiplying for "and" when the events are not independent. On one roll of a die, (the 4 only), not "And" means multiply only for independent events.
- Confusing independent with mutually exclusive. A head and a 6 are independent and can happen together: not 0. A 2 and a 5 on one roll are mutually exclusive: , not .
- Adding for "and". is not : both must happen, which cannot be more likely than either alone.
- Treating draws without replacement as independent. If the first ball is not put back, the bag has changed and the second draw's probabilities change (lesson 2.5).
- Missing a path. "One of each colour" is red then blue or blue then red: , not alone.
Practice
Try each question first, then open the solution to check your working.
Question 1
Are these events independent? Give a reason. (a) A fair coin is tossed and a fair die is rolled: a tail; a 3. (b) A card is drawn at random from a pack of 52 playing cards and put back, then a second card is drawn at random: the first card is red; the second card is red. (c) A sweet is taken from a bag and eaten, then a second sweet is taken: the first sweet is red; the second sweet is red. (d) A fair die is rolled once: an odd number; a 1.
ShowHide solution
(a) The coin does not affect the die: independent.
(b) The first card is put back, so the pack is the same for the second draw: independent.
(c) The first sweet is eaten, so the bag has changed for the second: not independent.
(d) A 1 makes "odd" certain: not independent. (Also while
(a) Yes; (b) yes; (c) no; (d) no.
Question 2
A red die and a blue die, both fair, are rolled. Find the probability that (a) the red die shows a 1 or a 2 and the blue die shows an odd number; (b) both dice show a number less than 5.
ShowHide solution
The dice are separate, so the events are independent.
(a) and
(b) for each die.
Check on a possibility diagram: (a) is a block of cells of 36; (b) a block of cells, and .
(a) ; (b) .
Question 3
Spinner A has three equal sectors numbered 1, 2 and 3. Spinner B has four equal sectors numbered 1, 2, 3 and 4. Both are spun. Find the probability that (a) spinner A shows 3 and spinner B shows 4; (b) both spinners show an even number.
ShowHide solution
The spinners are separate, so the events are independent.
(a) and
(b) Spinner A has one even number, 2: . Spinner B has two, 2 and 4: .
(a) ; (b) .
Question 4
A bag holds 4 green and 6 yellow marbles. A marble is taken at random, its colour is noted and it is put back; then a second marble is taken at random. Draw a tree diagram and find the probability that (a) both marbles are green; (b) both marbles are the same colour; (c) the marbles are of different colours.
ShowHide solution
With replacement, and at both draws.
(a)
(b) GG or YY:
(c) GY or YG: Check:
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Question 5
Hui Min takes the MRT and then a bus to school. The probability that the train is on time is 0.95 and the probability that the bus is on time is 0.8, and one does not affect the other. Find the probability that (a) both are on time; (b) the train is on time but the bus is late.
ShowHide solution
The events are independent.
(a) .
(b) .
(a) 0.76; (b) 0.19.
Question 6
and are independent events with and . Find (a) ; (b) the probability that neither nor happens.
ShowHide solution
(a) so and
(b) Draw a tree: or not first, then or not . does not change the chance of , so after and after not alike the branches are and Neither happens on the path not , not , and
(a) 0.3; (b) 0.42.
Question 7
A fair die is rolled once. Jun Hao says: "P(odd) is and P(prime) is , so the probability of a number that is odd and prime is ." Explain his mistake and find the correct probability.
ShowHide solution
Odd: 1, 3, 5. Prime: 2, 3, 5. Both events come from the same roll, and knowing that the number is odd changes the chance that it is prime: 2 of the 3 odd numbers are prime, against 3 of all 6 numbers. The events are not independent, so multiplying is wrong.
Count the outcomes in both: 3 and 5.
The events are not independent; not .
Question 8
and . Mei Ling says that and are mutually exclusive and independent. Show that she cannot be right.
ShowHide solution
If and were mutually exclusive, .
If they were independent,
cannot be both 0 and 0.15, so the events cannot be both. Mutually exclusive events whose probabilities are more than 0 are never independent.
Mutually exclusive needs ; independent needs 0.15: not both.
Question 9
Three friends each choose one of four stalls at a hawker centre at random, and no choice affects another. One of the stalls sells chicken rice. Find the probability that (a) all three choose the chicken rice stall; (b) all three choose the same stall.
ShowHide solution
(a) Each friend chooses chicken rice with probability , independently:
(b) "All at the same stall" means all at the first stall, or all at the second, and so on. Each of these 4 cases has probability , and no two can happen together, so add:
(a) ; (b) .
Question 10
The letters of the word SINGAPORE are written on nine cards. A card is chosen at random, its letter is noted and it is put back; then a second card is chosen at random. Find the probability that (a) both letters are vowels; (b) the first letter is S and the second is a vowel; (c) the same letter is chosen twice.
ShowHide solution
The vowels are I, A, O and E: 4 of the 9 cards. The card is put back, so the draws are independent.
(a)
(b)
(c) Whatever the first letter, the second card is the same one with probability (the nine letters are all different). Or: 9 outcomes of the are the same letter twice, .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
Question 11
In a football match, Farid and Hakim each take one penalty kick. The probability that Farid scores is 0.8 and the probability that Hakim scores is 0.6, and one kick does not affect the other. Find the probability that (a) both score; (b) exactly one of them scores; (c) neither scores.
ShowHide solution
Let S stand for "scores" and M for "misses". Farid: , . Hakim: , .
(a) .
(b) SM or MS:
(c) . Check:
(a) 0.48; (b) 0.44; (c) 0.08.
Key Points
- Two events are independent if whether one happens does not change the probability of the other.
- If and are independent, for three independent events, multiply all three probabilities.
- Separate dice, coins and spinners, and draws with replacement, give independent events.
- Mutually exclusive events whose probabilities are more than 0 are never independent: one happening makes the other impossible.
- "And" means multiply only for independent events or along a tree's path; "or" means add only for mutually exclusive events or separate paths.