Mutually Exclusive Events
Events that cannot happen at the same time, the addition rule P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B) that holds for them and only for them, and complementary events as a special case.
What You Should Already Know
- From Secondary 2: For a fair die,
- From lessons 2.1 and 2.2: an event's probability is found by counting the cells of a possibility diagram that are in it (when the cells are equally likely), or by adding the paths of a tree diagram that give it.
- From Secondary 2: a pack of 52 playing cards has 4 suits of 13 cards, hearts and diamonds (red), spades and clubs (black); each suit has an Ace, the numbers 2 to 10, a Jack, a Queen and a King.
Events That Cannot Happen Together
When a fair die is rolled once, it cannot show a 2 and a 5 at the same time: getting a 2 rules out getting a 5. When a card is drawn, though, it can be a heart and a King at the same time: the King of hearts is both.
Mutually exclusive events
Two events and are mutually exclusive if they cannot happen at the same time: no outcome is in both.
For mutually exclusive events, .
To show that two events are not mutually exclusive, find one outcome that is in both.
| Mutually exclusive | Not mutually exclusive |
|---|---|
| Getting a 2 and getting a 5 on one roll of a die | Getting an even number and getting a 4 on one roll of a die (4 is both) |
| Drawing a heart and drawing a spade when one card is drawn | Drawing a heart and drawing a King when one card is drawn (the King of hearts is both) |
| A student chosen at random is in Secondary 3, and is in Secondary 4 | A number chosen from 1 to 20 is even, and is a multiple of 3 (6, 12 and 18 are both) |
Example 1: Mutually exclusive or not?
Two fair dice are rolled. is the event "the sum is 7", is the event "the two numbers are the same" and is the event "the sum is even". Are (a) and ; (b) and mutually exclusive? Explain.
Solution
(a) Mark and on the possibility diagram of sums.
No cell is both shaded and ringed: a double has an even sum, up to , so it is never 7. and cannot happen together.
(b) Mark and .
Every double is shaded as well as ringed: (3, 3), for example, is a double with the even sum 6. and can happen together.
(a) and are mutually exclusive; (b) and are not, since (3, 3) is in both.
The Addition Rule
The outcomes of " or " are the outcomes of together with the outcomes of . When no outcome is in both, none is counted twice, so the numbers of outcomes add, and so do the probabilities.
Adding probabilities for "or"
If and are mutually exclusive,
This holds only for mutually exclusive events.
For three or more events, no two of which can happen together,
Example 2: A 2 or a 5
A fair die is rolled once. Find the probability of getting a 2 or a 5.
Solution
One roll cannot show a 2 and a 5, so the events are mutually exclusive.
Check by counting: 2 favourable outcomes, 2 and 5, out of 6.
.
Example 3: A sum of 7 or a double
Two fair dice are rolled. Find the probability that the sum is 7 or the two numbers are the same.
Solution
From the first diagram of Example 1, and and the events are mutually exclusive.
Check by counting: the shaded and ringed cells together are cells, none of them counted twice.
Example 4: Three colours
A bag holds 5 red, 3 blue and 4 green balls. One ball is drawn at random. Find the probability that it is (a) red or blue; (b) blue or green; (c) red, blue or green.
Solution
There are equally likely balls. A ball has only one colour, so any two colours are mutually exclusive.
(a)
(b)
(c) every ball is one of these colours, so the event is certain.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
When the Events Can Happen Together
If two events share an outcome, adding their probabilities counts that outcome twice, and the answer is too big. Do not add: count the outcomes of " or " directly, each once.
Example 5: A heart or a King
A card is drawn at random from a pack of 52 playing cards. Find the probability that it is a heart or a King.
Solution
A heart and a King can happen together: the King of hearts is both. The events are not mutually exclusive, so is wrong: it counts the King of hearts twice.
Count the cards instead: the 13 hearts (the King of hearts among them), and the Kings of the other three suits.
cards.
not .
Example 6: An even number or a 4
A fair die is rolled once. Wei Ming says that the probability of getting an even number or a 4 is . Find his mistake and the correct probability.
Solution
A 4 is an even number, so the two events happen together whenever a 4 is rolled. They are not mutually exclusive, and adding counts the 4 twice.
Count: the outcomes that are even or a 4 are 2, 4 and 6.
The events are not mutually exclusive;
Complementary Events
An event and the event "not " are mutually exclusive: an outcome cannot be in and not in . Between them they hold every outcome, so " or not " is certain, with probability 1.
Complementary events
and "not " are complementary events: they are mutually exclusive, and one of them must happen.
By the addition rule, so
Two mutually exclusive events are complementary only if together they hold every outcome.
Example 7: Neither a sum of 7 nor a double
Two fair dice are rolled. Find the probability that (a) the sum is not 7; (b) the sum is not 7 and the numbers are not the same.
Solution
(a) "The sum is not 7" is the complement of "the sum is 7".
(b) In the first diagram of Example 1, the outcomes that are not 7 and not a double are the cells neither shaded nor ringed: the 36 cells less the 12 of "a sum of 7 or a double", so cells. .
These 24 cells are all the cells outside "a sum of 7 or a double", so this is also (Example 3).
(a) ; (b) .
Example 8: Ways of travelling to school
Every student of a school travels to school in exactly one of four ways: by bus, by MRT, on foot or by car. For a student chosen at random, , and Find the probability that the student travels (a) by bus or by MRT; (b) by car; (c) in a way other than on foot.
Solution
Each student uses exactly one way, so the four events are mutually exclusive.
(a)
(b) The four ways hold every student, so their probabilities add up to 1:
(c) Check:
(a) 0.75; (b) 0.1; (c) 0.85.
Common Mistakes
- Adding for "or" when the events can happen together. On one roll of a die, is , not ; for one card, is , not . "Or" means add only for mutually exclusive events.
- Multiplying for "and" with mutually exclusive events. On one roll of a die, , not Lesson 2.4 shows when multiplying is right.
- Deciding that events are mutually exclusive because they seldom happen together. They must be impossible together: look for a single outcome in both.
- Calling two mutually exclusive events complementary. Getting a 1 and getting a 6 cannot happen together, but , not 1: other outcomes are left over.
Practice
Try each question first, then open the solution to check your working.
Question 1
A card is drawn at random from a pack of 52 playing cards. Are these events mutually exclusive? Give a reason. (a) A red card; a black card. (b) A diamond; a picture card (Jack, Queen or King). (c) An Ace; a King. (d) A club; a card that is not a 7.
ShowHide solution
(a) A card is red or black, never both: mutually exclusive (and complementary, as every card is one or the other).
(b) The Jack, Queen and King of diamonds are both: not mutually exclusive.
(c) A card cannot be an Ace and a King: mutually exclusive.
(d) The 2 of clubs, for one, is a club that is not a 7: not mutually exclusive.
(a) Yes; (b) no; (c) yes; (d) no.
Question 2
A spinner has a red sector of , a blue sector of and a green sector of . It is spun once. Find the probability that it lands on (a) red or blue; (b) not green.
ShowHide solution
(a) The pointer stops in one sector only, so red and blue are mutually exclusive.
(b) the same, since "not green" is "red or blue".
(a) ; (b) .
Question 3
A bag holds 6 red, 4 blue and 5 yellow counters. One counter is taken at random. Find the probability that it is (a) red or yellow; (b) not blue. Explain why the two answers are the same.
ShowHide solution
There are counters.
(a)
(b)
A counter that is not blue is red or yellow, so the two events are the same event.
(a) ; (b) ; "not blue" and "red or yellow" are the same event.
Question 4
A number is chosen at random from the whole numbers 1 to 20. is the event "a multiple of 4", is "a prime number" and is "a multiple of 5". (a) Are and mutually exclusive? Find . (b) Are and mutually exclusive? Find .
ShowHide solution
: 4, 8, 12, 16, 20 (5 numbers). : 2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19 (8 numbers). : 5, 10, 15, 20 (4 numbers).
(a) A multiple of 4 has 2 as a factor besides 1 and itself, so it is not prime: no number is in both. and are mutually exclusive.
(b) 5 is prime and a multiple of 5, so and are not mutually exclusive. Do not add; count the numbers in or , each once: 2, 3, 5, 7, 10, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19, 20. That is 11 numbers.
(a) Yes, ; (b) no, .
Question 5
Two fair dice are rolled. Find the probability that the sum is less than 4 or greater than 10.
ShowHide solution
A sum cannot be less than 4 and greater than 10 at once, so the events are mutually exclusive.
Less than 4: sums 2 and 3, cells. Greater than 10: sums 11 and 12, cells.
.
Question 6
A fair coin is tossed and a fair die is rolled. Explain why is not , and find it.
ShowHide solution
A head and a 6 can happen together (H6), so the events are not mutually exclusive, and adding counts H6 twice.
Count on the possibility diagram of the coin and the die (lesson 2.1): the 6 outcomes H1 to H6, and T6. That is 7 of the 12 outcomes.
(not
H6 is in both events;
Question 7
At a school canteen, each student buys exactly one lunch, from one of the stalls. For a student chosen at random, the probability of buying chicken rice is 0.42, noodles 0.31 and a sandwich 0.15. Find the probability that the student buys (a) chicken rice or noodles; (b) none of these three.
ShowHide solution
Each student buys one lunch, so the events are mutually exclusive.
(a) .
(b) and "none of the three" is its complement: .
(a) 0.73; (b) 0.12.
Question 8
A spinner has three equal sectors coloured red, blue and green. It is spun twice. Using the complement, find the probability that the two spins do not give the same colour.
ShowHide solution
Draw a possibility diagram (lesson 2.1): cells, all equally likely, as the sectors are equal.
The same colour: RR, BB or GG, the 3 shaded cells.
Check: the 6 cells not shaded give .
.
Question 9
Ali rolls a fair die once. He says: "P(even) is and P(prime) is , so getting an even number or a prime number is certain." Is he right? Find the probability.
ShowHide solution
Even: 2, 4, 6. Prime: 2, 3, 5. The number 2 is both, so the events are not mutually exclusive, and counts the 2 twice.
Even or prime: 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. Only a 1 is neither.
which is not certain.
No:
Question 10
The events , and are mutually exclusive (no two can happen together). , and Find (a) ; (b) ; (c) .
ShowHide solution
(a) so
(b)
(c)
(a) 0.25; (b) 0.75; (c) 0.5.
Question 11
In a lucky draw at a community centre, 200 tickets are sold and each ticket can win at most one prize. A ticket drawn at random has probability of winning the first prize, of winning a second prize and of winning a third prize. Find the probability that a ticket (a) wins a prize; (b) wins no prize.
ShowHide solution
A ticket wins at most one prize, so the three events are mutually exclusive.
(a)
(b)
(a) ; (b) .
Key Points
- Two events are mutually exclusive if they cannot happen at the same time; then .
- If and are mutually exclusive, for more events, no two of which can happen together, add all their probabilities.
- If the events can happen together, do not add: count the outcomes of " or ", each once.
- and "not " are complementary: mutually exclusive, and one of them must happen.
- One outcome in both events is enough to show they are not mutually exclusive.